Michele Fioretti,Victor Saint-Jean,Simon C. Smith
Abstract:We analyze the timing of NGO campaigns to shed light on NGOs' objectives and how their strategies evolve over time. Using data from 2,500 campaigns, we find that NGOs are eight times more likely to launch campaigns on Annual General Meeting (AGM) dates. These campaigns increase media exposure and stakeholder scrutiny, raising the likelihood of consumer boycotts and related shareholder proposals at the following AGM of the targeted firm but have no impact on current AGM votes. As NGOs build reputational capital, they adjust their timing to influence AGM outcomes, revealing the trade-offs they face to drive corporate change.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How can non - government organizations (NGOs) achieve their goals through strategic selection of the timing of campaigns, and how does this strategy evolve over time? Specifically, the author analyzes the timing of NGO campaigns launched before and after the company's annual general meeting (AGM) to reveal the goals of these organizations and their strategic changes.
### Main problem decomposition:
1. **Timing of NGO campaigns**:
- The author studied whether NGOs are more inclined to launch campaigns near the company's AGM date. Research shows that NGOs are eight times more likely to launch campaigns on the AGM date than at other times.
- This timing can increase media exposure and stakeholder attention, thereby increasing the likelihood of consumer boycotts and the passage of shareholder proposals.
2. **Trade - off between media exposure and influence**:
- NGOs face a crucial trade - off: whether to launch campaigns near the AGM date to obtain higher media exposure or to launch campaigns several months in advance to directly influence the voting results of the AGM.
- The study found that although campaigns near the AGM date can significantly increase media exposure, they have little impact on the voting results of the current AGM.
3. **Accumulation of NGO reputation and strategic adjustment**:
- As NGOs accumulate reputation, they gradually adjust the timing of their campaigns, from choosing to launch campaigns more often on the AGM date in the early days to choosing to launch campaigns two to three months before the AGM later to directly influence the voting results.
- This shows that NGOs will optimize their strategies according to their accumulated reputation to better achieve their goals.
4. **Success rate of shareholder proposals**:
- The study also found that the more times an NGO that supports a certain shareholder proposal has launched campaigns on past AGM dates, the greater the likelihood of the proposal's success.
- This reflects the importance of NGO reputation for its influence.
### Formula explanation:
To quantify the change in media exposure, the author used the following event - study model:
\[ \text{News}_{n,m,y} = \sum_{\tau = - 6}^{6} \beta_\tau\cdot1\{\text{m}=\tau\}\cdot\text{NGO Campaign}_{n,m,y}+X_{n,m,y}\gamma'+\alpha_{n,y}+\alpha_{m,y,s(n)}+u_{n,m,y} \]
where:
- \( \text{News}_{n,m,y} \) represents the number of news items of the company in month \( m \) of year \( y \).
- \( \beta_\tau \) is the regression coefficient, representing the media exposure change relative to the base period (\( \tau=-3 \)).
- \( 1\{\text{m}=\tau\} \) is a dummy variable, indicating whether the number of months \( m \) is equal to \( \tau \).
- \( \text{NGO Campaign}_{n,m,y} \) is a dummy variable, indicating whether there is an NGO campaign in month \( m \) of year \( y \) for the company.
- \( X_{n,m,y} \) contains other control variables.
- \( \alpha_{n,y} \) and \( \alpha_{m,y,s(n)} \) are company - year fixed effects and industry - month fixed effects respectively.
Through this model, the author can quantify the impact of NGO campaigns on media exposure in different time periods.
### Summary:
This paper reveals how these organizations balance between media exposure and direct influence and how this strategy evolves as their reputation accumulates by analyzing the timing of NGO campaigns. The research results provide a new perspective for understanding how NGOs promote social change through strategic campaigns.