Klaus M. Miller,Karlo Lukic,Bernd Skiera
Abstract:This study explores the impact of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), introduced on May 25th, 2018, on online trackers, vital elements in the online advertising ecosystem. Using a difference-in-differences approach with a balanced panel of 294 publishers, we compare publishers subject to the GDPR with those unaffected (the control group). Drawing on data from <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://WhoTracks.me" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>, which spans 32 months from May 2017 to December 2019, we analyze how the number of trackers used by publishers changed before and after the GDPR. The findings reveal that although online tracking increased for both groups, the rise was less significant for EU-based publishers subject to the GDPR. Specifically, the GDPR reduced about four trackers per publisher, equating to a 14.79% decrease compared to the control group. The GDPR was particularly effective in curbing privacy invasive trackers that collect and share personal data, thereby strengthening user privacy. However, it had a limited impact on advertising trackers and only slightly reduced the presence of analytics trackers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: to evaluate the impact of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) on the use of online trackers, especially whether it has effectively reduced the use of trackers with high privacy risks, and to explore the impact of GDPR on all parties involved in the online advertising market (users, publishers, advertisers and tracker providers).
### Specific problems include:
1. **The impact of GDPR on the amount of tracker use**:
- By comparing the changes in the number of trackers used by EU and non - EU publishers before and after the entry into force of GDPR, evaluate whether GDPR has reduced the use of trackers.
- Pay special attention to trackers with high privacy invasiveness (such as trackers that collect and share personal data) to determine whether GDPR has achieved the goal of reducing high - risk trackers.
2. **The impact of GDPR on different types of trackers**:
- Analyze the specific impact of GDPR on different types of trackers (such as advertising trackers, analytics trackers, etc.), and understand its effects in different application scenarios.
- Explore whether GDPR has a greater impact on certain types of trackers, for example, the differences between advertising trackers and analytics trackers.
3. **The impact of GDPR on market participants**:
- Research how GDPR affects the behaviors and strategies of users, publishers, advertisers and tracker providers.
- Evaluate whether GDPR has changed the ways in which these parties achieve their goals, for example, how publishers balance compliance and profitability, and how advertisers adjust their advertising placement strategies.
4. **The long - term impact of GDPR**:
- Explore the impact of GDPR on tracker use in the short - term (such as within three months) and in the long - term (such as six months later), and evaluate its continuity and stability.
- Analyze whether there are rebound effects or other unexpected consequences, such as increased market concentration or a disproportionate impact on small publishers.
### Methodology:
- **Research method**: Use the Difference - in - Differences (DiD) analysis to compare EU publishers affected by GDPR and non - EU publishers not affected.
- **Data source**: Use the data provided by WhoTracks.me, covering the data of 294 publishers during the 32 - month period from May 2017 to December 2019.
- **Classification system**: According to the goals of GDPR, classify trackers by purpose, necessity, tracking function, publisher type and tracker provider scale in order to analyze their impacts more meticulously.
Through the above - mentioned analysis, this paper aims to comprehensively understand the actual impact of GDPR on the use of online trackers, evaluate whether it has achieved the expected privacy protection goals, and provide references for future policy - making.