Diversity and Inclusion in AI for Recruitment: Lessons from Industry Workshop

Muneera Bano,Didar Zowghi,Fernando Mourao,Sarah Kaur,Tao Zhang
2024-11-09
Abstract:Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems for online recruitment markets have the potential to significantly enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of job placements and even promote fairness or inclusive hiring practices. Neglecting Diversity and Inclusion (D&I) in these systems, however, can perpetuate biases, leading to unfair hiring practices and decreased workplace diversity, while exposing organisations to legal and reputational risks. Despite the acknowledged importance of D&I in AI, there is a gap in research on effectively implementing D&I guidelines in real-world recruitment systems. Challenges include a lack of awareness and framework for operationalising D&I in a cost-effective, context-sensitive manner. This study aims to investigate the practical application of D&I guidelines in AI-driven online job-seeking systems, specifically exploring how these principles can be operationalised to create more inclusive recruitment processes. We conducted a co-design workshop with a large multinational recruitment company focusing on two AI-driven recruitment use cases. User stories and personas were applied to evaluate the impacts of AI on diverse stakeholders. Follow-up interviews were conducted to assess the workshop's long-term effects on participants' awareness and application of D&I principles. The co-design workshop successfully increased participants' understanding of D&I in AI. However, translating awareness into operational practice posed challenges, particularly in balancing D&I with business goals. The results suggest developing tailored D&I guidelines and ongoing support to ensure the effective adoption of inclusive AI practices.
Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to effectively implement the diversity and inclusion (D&I) principles in AI - driven online recruitment systems to ensure that these systems can operate fairly, transparently and inclusively. Specifically, the research focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Identifying challenges**: Explore the challenges in implementing D&I principles in AI recruitment systems, including the lack of awareness and frameworks, and the difficulty in operationalizing D&I in a cost - effective and context - sensitive manner. 2. **Formulating practical guidelines**: Through workshops co - designed with industry partners, explore how to transform D&I principles into specific and actionable practical guidelines to create a more inclusive recruitment process. 3. **Evaluating long - term impacts**: Through follow - up interviews, evaluate the long - term impact of the workshops on participants' understanding and application of D&I principles, ensuring that these principles can be continuously implemented in actual business. 4. **Balancing business goals and D&I**: Research how to effectively integrate D&I principles into the development and deployment processes of AI systems without affecting business goals. ### Research background With the wide application of AI technology in the online recruitment market, although it has improved the efficiency and effectiveness of recruitment, it may also perpetuate or exacerbate biases due to the neglect of D&I, leading to unfair recruitment practices and a reduction in workplace diversity. In addition, neglecting D&I will also expose organizations to legal and reputational risks. Therefore, how to effectively implement D&I principles in AI systems has become an urgent problem to be solved. ### Methods To achieve the above - mentioned goals, the research team cooperated with SEEK Company and carried out the following activities: 1. **Pre - work preparation**: Identify two AI - driven recruitment use cases and generate user stories to reflect the impact of D&I. 2. **Co - design workshop**: Through the workshop, let participants generate and prioritize user stories and explore how to apply D&I principles in specific use cases. 3. **Post - evaluation**: Through follow - up interviews, evaluate the long - term effects of the workshop, collect feedback and improve the D&I guidelines. ### Results The research results show that the co - design workshop significantly improved participants' understanding of D&I principles, but there are still challenges in translating this understanding into practical operations, especially in balancing D&I and business goals. The research recommends developing customized D&I guidelines and providing continuous support to ensure the effective adoption of inclusive AI practices. ### Contributions This research provides valuable insights into the practical application of D&I principles in AI - driven recruitment systems, emphasizes the importance of stakeholder participation, and proposes a framework to improve the inclusiveness in SEEK Company's AI systems. In addition, the research results can also be used as a reference model for other industries to ensure inclusive AI processes. ### Summary This paper, through empirical research, explores how to effectively implement D&I principles in AI recruitment systems, providing important theoretical and practical guidance for promoting fairer, more transparent and inclusive recruitment processes.