Dena F. Mujtaba,Nihar R. Mahapatra
Abstract:The recruitment process is crucial to an organization's ability to position itself for success, from finding qualified and well-fitting job candidates to impacting its output and culture. Therefore, over the past century, human resources experts and industrial-organizational psychologists have established hiring practices such as attracting candidates with job ads, gauging a candidate's skills with assessments, and using interview questions to assess organizational fit. However, the advent of big data and machine learning has led to a rapid transformation in the traditional recruitment process as many organizations have moved to using artificial intelligence (AI). Given the prevalence of AI-based recruitment, there is growing concern that human biases may carry over to decisions made by these systems, which can amplify the effect through systematic application. Empirical studies have identified prevalent biases in candidate ranking software and chatbot interactions, catalyzing a growing body of research dedicated to AI fairness over the last decade. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of this emerging field by discussing the types of biases encountered in AI-driven recruitment, exploring various fairness metrics and mitigation methods, and examining tools for auditing these systems. We highlight current challenges and outline future directions for developing fair AI recruitment applications, ensuring equitable candidate treatment and enhancing organizational outcomes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly discusses the issue of fairness in the recruitment process of artificial intelligence (AI). With the development of big data and machine learning, many organizations have started to use AI for recruitment, but this has also raised concerns about the possibility of amplifying and spreading human biases through AI systems. Research has found that AI-driven recruitment software and chatbots have widespread biases, leading to increased attention to fairness.
The paper first emphasizes the importance of recruitment for organizational success and outlines the evolution from traditional recruitment to digital recruitment (including the use of AI). The applications of AI in recruitment include creating job advertisements, tracking applicants, conducting video interviews, and implementing assessments. However, AI systems' decisions may exhibit human biases, such as the gender discrimination issues in Google and Amazon's recruitment tools.
The paper then discusses the definitions of fairness, trust, and justice, as well as relevant ethical and legal regulations, such as GDPR and the US Department of Defense's AI ethics principles. The authors also analyze various causes of bias in AI systems, including biased training data, label definitions, feature selection, proxies, and masking.
The paper examines various stages of the recruitment process (such as sourcing, screening, interviewing, and selection), identifies types of biases that may arise in these stages, and proposes various fairness metrics and mitigation strategies. In addition, the paper highlights the limitations of existing tools and methods and suggests future research directions aimed at developing fair AI recruitment applications to ensure fair treatment of candidates and improve organizational outcomes.
In conclusion, the paper seeks to address the problem of understanding and addressing fairness issues in AI-driven recruitment processes and ensuring fairness and transparency through fair AI practices in the recruitment process.