From Pen to Prompt: How Creative Writers Integrate AI into their Writing Practice

Alicia Guo,Shreya Sathyanarayanan,Leijie Wang,Jeffrey Heer,Amy Zhang
2024-11-05
Abstract:Creative writers have a love for their craft, yet AI systems using large language models (LLMs) offer the automation of significant parts of the writing process. So why do some creative writers choose to integrate AI into their workflows? To explore this, we interview and observe a writing session with 18 creative writers who already use AI regularly in their writing practice. Our findings reveal that creative writers are intentional about how they incorporate AI, making many deliberate decisions about when and how to engage AI based on the core values they hold about writing. These values, such as authenticity and craftsmanship, alongside writers' relationships with and use of AI influence the parts of writing over which they wish to maintain control. Through our analysis, we contribute a taxonomy of writer values, writer relationships with AI, and integration strategies, and discuss how these three elements interrelate.
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How creative writers integrate language - based generative AI into their writing practices, and the interplay between values, relationships, and strategies they face in this process.** Specifically, through interviewing and observing 18 creative writers who have already integrated AI into their daily writing, the researchers explored the following key questions: 1. **RQ1: Under what circumstances do creative writers use AI? Why do they use AI?** - The study found that writers use AI to gain inspiration or provide a starting point when they encounter creative bottlenecks. For example, AI can help them overcome "blank - page syndrome" and reduce the mental burden of thinking about what to write next. - AI is also used as a productivity - enhancing tool to help writers complete different stages of work more quickly, such as research, draft writing, story expansion, and editing tasks. - For some writers, AI is also an important assistive tool, especially when facing physical or mental health challenges. 2. **RQ2: How do creative writers negotiate with their own values in the process of using AI?** - Writers attach great importance to maintaining their unique writing styles and authenticity. For example, they will carefully evaluate the content generated by AI to ensure that the final work reflects their true voices. - Writers will also decide whether to use AI according to their personal preferences for different parts of writing. For example, for parts they don't like (such as plot design or description), they will rely more on AI so that they can concentrate more on the creative parts they love. 3. **RQ3: How do creative writers integrate AI into their writing processes?** - Writers are very purposeful when using AI and will dynamically adjust their relationships with AI. For example, some writers regard AI as an inspiration - inspiring partner, while others regard it as a ghostwriter, responsible for writing in the author's style but not participating in creative decisions. - Although AI can generate text or provide inspiration, writers still believe that the final work is shaped by their creative visions and decisions, so they retain a strong sense of control and ownership over the work. Through these studies, the authors revealed the complex mindsets and strategies of creative writers when using AI, emphasizing how writers maintain their unique understanding and value pursuit of writing while using AI. This not only provides references for other writers but also provides guidance for designing AI tools that better meet the needs of writers.