Holding the Line: A Study of Writers' Attitudes on Co-creativity with AI

Morteza Behrooz,Yuandong Tian,William Ngan,Yael Yungster,Justin Wong,David Zax
2024-04-20
Abstract:Generative AI has put many professional writers on the defensive; a major negotiation point of the recent Writers Guild of America's strike concerned use of AI. However, must AI threaten writers, their livelihoods or their creativity? And under what conditions, if any, might AI assistance be invited by different types of writers (from the amateur to the professional, from the screenwriter to the novelist)? To explore these questions, we conducted a qualitative study with 37 writers. We found that most writing occurs across five stages and within one of three modes; we additionally map openness to AI assistance to each intersecting stage-mode. We found that most writers were interested in AI assistance to some degree, but some writers felt drawing firm boundaries with an AI was key to their comfort using such systems. Designers can leverage these insights to build agency-respecting AI products for writers.
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is exploring how artificial intelligence (AI) in story creation is accepted and used by different types of writers in co-creativity. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **The process and needs of creative writing**: Investigating the different stages and patterns of creative writing, as well as the specific needs of writers at each stage and pattern. 2. **Acceptance of AI assistance**: Exploring which stages and patterns of writing are more open to AI assistance and which situations are more resistant. 3. **Design principles and capabilities**: Proposing design principles and AI capabilities to support effective co-creativity in story writing. Through these studies, the paper aims to provide guidance for designers to help them develop AI products that respect writers' autonomy and promote effective collaboration between humans and AI.