Flexural Behavior and Design of Prestressed Ultra-High Performance Concrete (UHPC) Beams: Failure Mode and Ductility

Xin Tian,Zhi Fang,Yi Shao

2024-11-02

Abstract:Ultra-high performance concrete (UHPC) is well-known for its ultra-high compressive strength and sustained post-cracking tensile ductility, making it an attractive choice for the construction of modern structures. Prestressed UHPC members, however, often fail quickly after crack localization accompanied by reinforcement rupture, which shows limited failure warnings (i.e., relatively small ductility, nearly invisible cracking, and negligible compressive damage). On the other hand, UHPC members can also be designed to allow the gradual strain hardening of reinforcement to compensate for the load loss due to crack localization, and the final failure is attributed to gradual crushing of UHPC prior to reinforcement rupture. Failure after gradual strain hardening is desirable since it brings warning signs through high ductility, visible cracks, and controlled spalling. To achieve a resilient structural design of UHPC members, this study aims to develop design methods to avoid early failure after crack localization and promote failure after gradual strain hardening. This study first establishes a three-dimensional finite-element analysis (FEA) model to simulate the flexural behavior of prestressed UHPC beams, which is validated against seven existing experimental beams. Then, parametric analyses are conducted to assess the influence of five key aspects, including the steel rebar-to-prestressing strand ratio, the post-yield hardening of mild steel rebars, the pretensioned stress of prestressing strands, the tensile behavior of UHPC, and the web width to bottom flange ratio. Additionally, the authors propose a design method to predict the failure mode of prestressed UHPC beams, which can be used to guide the design of reinforcement configuration and to promote ductile structural behavior.

Numerical Analysis

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to improve the ductile behavior of prestressed Ultra - High Performance Concrete (UHPC) beams, avoid their rapid failure after crack localization, and promote a more controllable and warning - enabled failure mode through the progressive strain hardening of reinforcing bars. Specifically:

1. **Brittle failure problem**: Prestressed UHPC beams usually fail rapidly after crack localization, accompanied by the rupture of reinforcing bars. This failure mode has almost no obvious warning signs (such as low ductility, almost invisible cracks, and negligible crushing damage). Therefore, the research aims to avoid this early brittle failure.

2. **Ductile failure mode**: By design, the UHPC beam can gradually harden after crack localization, thereby compensating for the load loss caused by crack localization and finally failing due to the gradual crushing of UHPC. This ductile failure mode is more desirable because it provides higher ductility, visible cracks, and controlled spalling, bringing more warning signs.

To achieve this goal, the author adopts the following methods:

- **Establish a three - dimensional finite - element analysis model**: Use the Concrete Damage Plasticity (CDP) model in ABAQUS to simulate the flexural behavior of prestressed UHPC beams. This model has been verified and can accurately capture the load - deflection response, maximum load - carrying capacity, crack pattern, and failure mode.

- **Parameter analysis**: Evaluate the influence of five key factors on the behavior of prestressed UHPC beams, including the ratio of reinforcing bars to prestressed strands, the post - yield hardening behavior of ordinary reinforcing bars, the pretension of prestressed strands, the tensile behavior of UHPC, and the ratio of web width to bottom flange.

- **Propose a design method**: Based on the above analysis, propose a design method to predict the failure mode of prestressed UHPC beams and guide the design of reinforcing bar arrangements to promote ductile structural behavior. In particular, a minimum reinforcement ratio threshold for ordinary reinforcing bars is proposed to design a progressive strain - hardening failure mode.

Through these measures, the research aims to develop a robust design method to ensure that prestressed UHPC beams have higher safety and reliability in practical applications.