Abstract:This paper consider a new and deeply challenging face of the problem of time in the context of cosmology drawing on the work of Thiemann (2006). Thiemann argues for a radical response to cosmic problem of time that requires us to modify the classical Friedmann equations. By contrast, we offer a conservative proposal for solution of the problem by bringing together ideas from the contemporary literature regarding reference frames (Bamonti 2023; Bamonti and Gomes 2024), complete observables (Gryb and Thébault 2016, 2023), and the model-based account of time measurement (Tal 2016). On our approach, we must reinterpret our criteria of observability in light of the clock hypothesis and the model-based account of measurement in order to preserve the Friedmann equations as the dynamical equations for the universe.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore a new and extremely challenging aspect of the time problem in cosmology, based on the work of Thiemann (2006). Specifically, the paper focuses on how to re - interpret the criteria of observability while maintaining the classical Friedmann equations, in order to solve the cosmic time problem. ### Background and problem formulation 1. **Space - time symmetry and time evolution**: - The diffeomorphism invariance of space - time in general relativity seems to imply that time itself is just a shadow, which contradicts the concept of cosmic time commonly used in cosmology. - Cosmic time is well - defined in any relativistic cosmology with a stable causal structure and is consistent with the space - time symmetry of general relativity. 2. **Observability of cosmic time**: - From an observational perspective, there are doubts as to whether cosmic time can be regarded as an independent physical observable. First, it does not directly correspond to a measurable quantity in the theory. Second, a true observable should be relational, that is, they correspond to correlations between measurable quantities, and cosmic time does not conform to this form. 3. **Cosmic time in the canonical form**: - In the canonical form of general relativity, neither cosmic time nor the scale factor \(a\) are Dirac observables. According to the Dirac criterion, observables must be phase - space functions whose weak Poisson brackets with the Hamiltonian constraint that generates the dynamics of the Friedmann equations are zero. However, neither cosmic time nor the scale factor satisfies this condition. 4. **Challenges of the Friedmann equations**: - The Friedmann equations describe the evolution of the scale factor \(a\) with cosmic time \(t\) during the expansion of the universe. These equations can be expressed as Hamiltonian equations, but according to the Dirac criterion, they should not be regarded as dynamical equations but as gauge transformation equations. This leads to a serious conflict, since the Friedmann equations are widely regarded as dynamical equations describing observables in cosmology. ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **Conservative scheme**: - The author proposes a conservative scheme to re - interpret the criteria of observability by combining reference frames, complete observables and model - based time - measurement methods, in order to maintain the validity of the Friedmann equations as equations of cosmic dynamics. 2. **Clock hypothesis and Hubble flow**: - The author introduces the concept of Hubble flow and uses it as an appropriate parameter \(\tau\) for cosmic time. They discuss the observability and measurability of the Hubble parameter \(H=\frac{\dot{a}}{a}\), and propose a more relaxed concept of "measurement procedure" to solve the problem of measuring proper time along the Hubble flow. 3. **Methodology and significance**: - This paper not only provides a new perspective on the cosmic time problem, but also explores the methodological status of the clock hypothesis in cosmology and the meaning of "measurability". By synthesizing the key ideas in the current literature, the author provides a new framework for solving the cosmic time problem. ### Conclusion The paper provides a conservative method to solve the cosmic time problem by re - interpreting the criteria of observability while maintaining the validity of the Friedmann equations. This method not only helps to understand the time problem in cosmology, but also provides new directions for future research.

In Search of Cosmic Time: Complete Observables and the Clock Hypothesis

On the nature of cosmological time

Time and Quantum Clocks: a review of recent developments

Finding Time for Wheeler-DeWitt Cosmology

Cosmic time and the initial state of the universe

Freeze-free cosmological evolution with a non-monotonic internal clock

Cosmic-time quantum mechanics and the passage-of-time problem

Measuring time in a timeless universe

General Covariance and the "Problem of Time" in a Discrete Cosmology

Cosmology in Time Asymmetric Extensions of General Relativity

The semiclassical limit of quantum gravity and the problem of time

Addressing the Hubble tension with cosmic chronometers

Time-dependent cosmological interpretation of quantum mechanics

Measuring time with stationary quantum clocks

The problem with `The Problem of Time'

A cognitive basis for physical time

Unimodular-like times, evolution and Brans-Dicke Gravity

On the nature of discrete space-time: The atomic theory of space-time and its effects on Pythagoras's theorem, time versus duration, inertial anomalies of astronomical bodies, and special relativity at the Planck scale

Cosmology in Minkowski space

Geometry and proper time of a relativistic quantum clock

What is Time? A New Mathematico- Physical and Information Theoretic Approach