Abstract:A fundamental description of time can be consistent not only with the usual monotonic behavior but also with an oscillating physical clock variable, coupled to the degrees of freedom of a system evolving in time. Generically, one would in fact expect some kind of oscillating motion of a system that is dynamical and interacts with its surroundings, as required for a fundamental clock that can be noticed by any other system. Unitary evolution does not require a monotonic clock variable and can be achieved more generally by formally unwinding the oscillating clock movement, keeping track not only of the value of the clock variable but also of the number of cycles it has gone through at any moment. The specific treatment used here employs concatenations of evolution operators, alternating between forward and backward evolution of the oscillating clock. Because the clock and an evolving system have a common conserved energy, the clock is in different cycles for different energy eigenstates of the system state. As a result, the clock is generically in a quantum state with a superposition of different clock cycles, a key feature that distinguishes oscillating clocks from monotonic time. In addition, coherence could be lost faster than observed, for instance if a system that would be harmonic in isolation is made anharmonic by interactions with a fundamental clock, implying observational bounds on fundamental clocks. Numerical computations show that coherence is maintained over long timescales provided the clock period is much smaller than the system period. A small loss of coherence nevertheless remains and, measured in terms of the relative standard deviation of the system period, is proportional to the ratio of the system period and the clock period. Since the precision of atomic clocks could not be achieved if atomic frequencies would be subject to additional variations from coupling to a fundamental clock, an upper bound on the clock period can be obtained that turns out to be much smaller than currently available direct or indirect measurements of time. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.105.106020 © 2022 American Physical Society

Measuring time in a timeless universe

Measuring time with stationary quantum clocks

Measurement events relative to temporal quantum reference frames

Robustness of the Page-Wootters construction across different pictures, states of the universe and system-clock interactions

The quantum clock: a critical discussion on space-time

(Un)physical consequences of "Quantum Measurements of Time"

Measurement in a Unitary World

Relational evolution with oscillating clocks

A cognitive basis for physical time

Measurement-induced Clock in a Lattice Ring of Non-interacting Electrons

Time evolution in quantum mechanics with a minimal time scale

A magnetic clock for a harmonic oscillator

The Time's Arrow within the Uncertainty Quantum

Measuring the Subjective Passage of Time

Subsystems and time in quantum mechanics

Time and Quantum Clocks: a review of recent developments

Clocks without "Time" in Entangled-State Experiments

Freeze-free cosmological evolution with a non-monotonic internal clock

Interference of Clocks: A Quantum Twin Paradox

Quantum time in near-horizon region of a black hole

Unraveling the Mystery of Quantum Measurement with A New Space-Time Approach to Relativistic Quantum Mechanics