Do Neutron Star Ultra-Luminous X-Ray Sources Masquerade as Intermediate Mass Black Holes in Radio and X-Ray?

Teresa Panurach,Kristen C. Dage,Ryan Urquhart,Richard M. Plotkin,Jeremiah D. Paul,Arash Bahramian,McKinley C. Brumback,Timothy J. Galvin,Isabella Molina,James C. A. Miller-Jones,Payaswini Saikia

2024-10-31

Abstract:Ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs) were once largely believed to be powered by super-Eddington accretion onto stellar-mass black holes, although in some rare cases, ULXs also serve as potential candidates for (sub-Eddington) intermediate mass black holes. However, a total of eight ULXs have now been confirmed to be powered by neutron stars, thanks to observed pulsations, and may act as contaminants for radio/X-ray selection of intermediate mass black holes. Here we present the first comprehensive radio study of seven known neutron star ULXs using new and archival data from the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array and the Australia Telescope Compact Array, combined with the literature. Across this sample there is only one confident radio detection, from the Galactic neutron star ULX Swift J0243.6+6124. The other six objects in our sample are extragalactic, and only one has coincident radio emission, which we conclude is most likely contamination from a background HII region. We conclude that with current facilities, neutron star ULXs do not produce significant enough radio emission to cause them to be misidentified as radio/X-ray selected intermediate mass black hole candidates. Thus, if background star formation has been properly considered, the current study indicates that a ULX with a compact radio counterpart is not likely to be a neutron star.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore whether ultra - luminous X - ray sources (ULXs) could be misidentified as manifestations of intermediate - mass black holes (IMBHs) in the radio and X - ray bands. Specifically, the researchers focus on the characteristics of ULXs known to be driven by neutron stars in the radio band and evaluate whether these characteristics could cause these ULXs to be misidentified as IMBHs.

### Background and motivation

1. **Traditional understanding of ULXs**:
- ULXs were initially thought to be driven by stellar - mass black holes through super - Eddington accretion.
- Some ULXs were considered as potential intermediate - mass black hole (IMBHs) candidates.

2. **Discovery of neutron - star ULXs**:
- In recent years, through the observed pulse signals, eight ULXs have been confirmed to actually be driven by neutron stars.
- The existence of these neutron - star ULXs challenges the traditional ULXs model and raises a question: will these neutron - star ULXs exhibit characteristics similar to IMBHs in the radio and X - ray bands, thus leading to misjudgment?

3. **Relationship between radio and X - ray**:
- At low accretion rates, the radio - to - X - ray luminosity ratio (\( \frac{L_R}{L_X} \)) can be used to distinguish black - hole candidates from other types of accreting compact objects.
- Black - hole X - ray binaries (XRBs) usually show compact radio emission in the hard X - ray spectral state, which originates from a partially self - absorbed synchrotron jet.
- Through the correlation between radio and X - ray luminosities (fundamental plane of black - hole activity), black holes of different masses can be further distinguished.

### Research objectives

1. **Evaluate the radio characteristics of neutron - star ULXs**:
- Analyze the radio observation data of known neutron - star ULXs to evaluate the characteristics of these ULXs in the radio band.
- Pay special attention to whether these ULXs will produce enough radio emission to be misidentified as IMBHs.

2. **Verify the effectiveness of the selection method**:
- By comparing the radio - to - X - ray luminosity ratios of neutron - star ULXs and IMBHs, evaluate the effectiveness of using these ratios to select IMBHs.

3. **Provide new insights**:
- Provide new insights into the radio characteristics of neutron - star ULXs for future research, which will help to better understand the properties of these celestial bodies and their distribution outside the Milky Way.

### Methods

1. **Sample selection**:
- Select seven known neutron - star ULXs with radio observation data.
- The sample includes M82 X - 2, NGC 5907 ULX - 1, M51 ULX - 7, Swift J0243, NGC 300 X - 1, NGC 1313 X - 2 and NGC 7793 P13.

2. **Data collection and processing**:
- Use the archived data of the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) and the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA).
- Re - extract and model the X - ray data of each source to calculate the X - ray flux in the 1 - 10 keV range.

3. **Data analysis**:
- Analyze the radio and X - ray data of each source and calculate the radio - to - X - ray luminosity ratio.
- Evaluate whether these ratios conform to the characteristics of intermediate - mass black holes.

### Results

1. **Radio detection results**:
- Among the seven neutron - star ULXs, only one source (Swift J0243) has a definite radio detection.
- The other six sources either have no radio emission detected or the detected signal may be contaminated by the background HII region.

2. **Conclusion**:
- Under the current observational facilities, neutron - star ULXs will not produce enough radio emission to be misidentified as IMBHs.
- Therefore, if the background star formation has...