Exploring the nature of ultra-luminous X-ray sources across stellar population ages using detailed binary evolution calculations

Devina Misra,Konstantinos Kovlakas,Tassos Fragos,Jeff J. Andrews,Simone S. Bavera,Emmanouil Zapartas,Zepei Xing,Aaron Dotter,Kyle Akira Rocha,Philipp M. Srivastava,Meng Sun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202347880
2023-12-21
Abstract:Ultra-luminous X-ray sources (ULXs) are sources observed to exceed the Eddington limit of a stellar-mass black hole (BH). A fraction of ULX sources show X-ray pulses which are evidence for accreting neutron stars (NSs). Theoretical studies have suggested that NSs dominate the compact objects of intrinsic ULXs, even though the majority of observed sample is non-pulsating, implying that X-ray pulses from many NS ULXs are unobservable. We use POSYDON to generate and study X-ray binary populations spanning starburst ages 5 to 1000Myr. Following theoretical predictions for the alignment of the NS spin axis with the accretion disc, we estimate the required accreted mass in ULXs so that the alignment suppresses observable X-ray pulses. While the properties of ULXs are sensitive to model assumptions, there are certain trends that the populations follow. Young and old stellar populations are dominated by BH and NS accretors, respectively. The donors go from massive H-rich main-sequence (MS) stars in young populations (<100Myr) to low-mass post-MS H-rich stars in older populations (>100Myr), with stripped He-rich giant stars dominating the populations at around 100Myr. In addition, we find that NS ULXs exhibit stronger geometrical beaming than BH ULXs, leading to an under-representation of NS accretors in observed populations. Coupled with our finding that X-ray pulses are suppressed in at least 60% of the NS ULXs, we suggest that the observed fraction of ULXs with detectable X-ray pulses is very small, in agreement with observations. This study investigates the effects of age on ULXs as well as the effects of different model assumptions on ULX demographics. We show that geometrical beaming and the mass-accretion phase are critical aspects of understanding ULX observations. Our results suggest that even though most ULXs have accreting NSs, those with observable X-ray pulses would be very few.
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore the nature of ultraluminous X - ray sources (ULXs) at different stellar population ages. Specifically, through detailed binary star evolution calculations, the author simulated the X - ray binary star populations across the stellar burst age range from 5 to 1000 million years to compare the properties of ULXs observed at different age stages. In addition, the paper also compared two models that describe different physical process assumptions, which affect the mechanism of binary star evolution. ### Problems the paper attempts to solve: 1. **Properties of ULXs**: Study the properties of ULXs at different stellar population ages, especially the type of central compact object (CO), namely neutron star (NS) or black hole (BH). 2. **Observation bias**: Explore why most of the observed ULXs have no detected X - ray pulses, while theoretical predictions suggest that many ULXs should contain accreting neutron stars. 3. **Geometric beaming effect**: Analyze the impact of geometric beaming effect on ULXs observations and explain why the X - ray pulses of some ULXs are suppressed. ### Main methods: - **Population synthesis code**: Use the newly developed POSYDON code to generate multiple ULXs populations covering different stellar burst ages. - **X - ray luminosity calculation**: Adopt the super - Eddington accretion disk model to estimate the luminosity of ULXs and take into account the geometric beaming effect. - **Model assumptions**: Compare two different model assumptions, including parameters such as the birth rate of neutron stars and black holes, and the common envelope efficiency. ### Key findings: - **Differences between young and old populations**: Young stellar populations are mainly dominated by black hole accretors, while old stellar populations are mainly dominated by neutron star accretors. - **Changes in donor stars**: Donor stars in young populations (< 100 Myr) are mainly massive hydrogen - rich main - sequence stars, while donor stars in older populations (> 100 Myr) are low - mass post - main - sequence hydrogen - rich stars. - **Geometric beaming effect**: Neutron star ULXs exhibit a stronger geometric beaming effect, resulting in a smaller number of observed neutron star accretors. - **Suppression of X - ray pulses**: At least 60% of the X - ray pulses of neutron star ULXs are suppressed, which explains why the proportion of observed ULXs with detectable X - ray pulses is very small. ### Conclusions: - **Geometric beaming and accretion processes**: Geometric beaming effect and accretion processes are key factors in understanding ULXs observations. - **Prevalence of neutron star ULXs**: Although most ULXs may contain accreting neutron stars, the number of ULXs with detectable X - ray pulses is very small. Through these studies, the paper provides important theoretical support for understanding the nature of ULXs and their observational characteristics.