Abstract:This paper presents an expository reverse-mathematical analysis of two fundamental theorems in commutative algebra: Hilbert's Nullstellensatz and Basis Theorem. In addition to its profound significance in commutative algebra and algebraic geometry, the Basis Theorem is also historically notable for its nonconstructive proof. The Nullstellensatz, on the other hand, is noteworthy as it establishes a fundamental connection between the more algebraic notion of ideals and the more geometric notion of varieties. We explore the conscious shift from computational to conceptual approaches in mathematical argumentation, contextualizing Hilbert's contributions. We formalize the relative constructivity of these theorems using the framework of reverse mathematics, although we do not presuppose familiarity with reverse mathematics. Drawing from contemporary mathematical literature, we analyze the Basis Theorem's reliance on nonconstructive methods versus the more constructive nature of the Nullstellensatz. Our study employs the standard tools of reverse mathematics, in particular subsystems of second-order arithmetic, to outline the minimal set-existence axioms required for these theorems. We review results showing that certain formulations of the Nullstellensatz are provable in the weak axiom system of $\mathsf{RCA}_0$, while the Basis Theorem requires stronger axioms, such as $\Sigma^0_2$-Induction. Consequently, we position these theorems separately within the Friedman-Simpson hierarchy. This analysis contributes to a deeper understanding of the foundational requirements for these pivotal results in algebra.

Ludwig Bieberbach's "Remarks on Hilbert's Thirteenth Problem" and Addendum

Hilbert's Program Then and Now

Finitude géométrique en géométrie de Hilbert + an erratum/addendum

A Translation of "Die Normalfunktionen und das Problem der ausgezeichneten Folgen von Ordnungszahlen" by Heinz Bachmann

A note on a recent attempt to solve the second part of Hilbert's 16th Problem

A High-School Algebra and high-school (purely formal) calculus,. Wallet-Sized Proof, of the Bieberbach Conjecture [after L. Weinstein]

Hilbert, logicism, and mathematical existence

An elementary proof of Hilbert's theorem on ternary quartics: Some complements

A high-school algebra wallet-sized proof, of the Bieberbach conjecture After L. Weinstein]

Some Questions around The Hilbert 16th Problem

Various considerations on hypergeometric series

An introduction to univalent function theory and the Bieberbach conjecture

On the determination of the degree of an equation obtained by elimination (translation with commentary)

A Reverse Mathematical Analysis of Hilbert's Nullstellensatz and Basis Theorem

Intermediate Diophantine exponents and parametric geometry of numbers

Banach's theorem in higher order reverse mathematics

Ein Satz Über die Diophantische Gleichung $Ax^{2}-By^{4}=C$ ($C=1,2,4)$

Heinrich Behmann's 1921 lecture on the decision problem and the algebra of logic

Jacob's ladders, almost exact decomposition of certain increments of the Hardy-Littlewood integral (1918) by means of the Raabe's integral and the thirteenth equivalent of the Fermat-Wiles theorem

Notes on Hilbert's 16th: experiencing Viro's theory

Bieberbach conjecture, Bohr radius, Bloch constant and Alexander's theorem in infinite dimensions