Chatbot Companionship: A Mixed-Methods Study of Companion Chatbot Usage Patterns and Their Relationship to Loneliness in Active Users

Auren R. Liu,Pat Pataranutaporn,Sherry Turkle,Pattie Maes
2024-10-29
Abstract:As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly sophisticated, companion chatbots have been proposed as a potential solution to the growing epidemic of loneliness. However, the impact of these AI companions on users' psychological well-being and social behaviors remains poorly understood. This study presents a large-scale survey (n = 404) of regular users of companion chatbots, investigating the relationship between chatbot usage and their experience of loneliness. We find a small but significant direct correlation between session length with chatbots and loneliness, and we develop a model of this relationship through multiple regression analysis, finding social attraction and neuroticism as moderators. We find seven clusters of users, including socially fulfilled dependent users to lonely dependent users. Our work contributes to the ongoing dialogue about the role of AI in social and emotional support, offering insights for what kind of human-AI connections might lead to emotional well-being and complement rather than replace human connections.
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore and understand the usage patterns of companion chatbots and their relationship with users' loneliness. Specifically, the research attempts to answer the following key questions: 1. **RQ1: What are the motives for using companion chatbots? What do people use them for?** - The research investigates the motives and specific uses of users for companion chatbots through descriptive statistics and free - response methods. 2. **RQ2: What is the relationship between the use of companion chatbots and loneliness? Which factors play an intermediary or moderating role between the two?** - The research explores the relationship between the duration of chatbot use and loneliness through correlation analysis and multiple regression analysis, and identifies possible mediating variables (such as social interaction) and moderating variables (such as social attractiveness and neuroticism). 3. **RQ3: Can different user groups be identified and described based on usage patterns, loneliness levels, problematic use situations, and other psychological and social factors?** - The research identifies seven different user groups through K - means clustering analysis, ranging from socially satisfied dependent users to lonely dependent users. ### Research background With the development of artificial intelligence technology, companion chatbots have been proposed as a potential solution to deal with the increasingly serious problem of loneliness. However, the impact of these AI companions on users' mental health and social behavior has not been fully understood. Although some studies have shown that even short - term use of AI companions can reduce loneliness, there are also concerns about the authenticity of this relationship, which may lead to unrealistic relationship expectations and further cause social withdrawal. ### Research objectives To fill this knowledge gap in this field, the researchers conducted a large - scale survey (n = 404) on users who regularly use companion chatbots and analyzed them through the following methods: - **Statistical analysis**: including correlation analysis and multiple regression analysis. - **Clustering analysis**: used to identify different types of user groups. - **Qualitative assessment**: through qualitative analysis of user feedback to gain in - depth understanding of users' motives and usage characteristics. ### Main contributions 1. **Established a model** to explain the relationship between the use of companion chatbots and loneliness, considering socialization as a mediating variable and social attractiveness and neuroticism as moderating variables. 2. **Proposed a user classification system** based on usage patterns, psychological characteristics, and perceived benefits or drawbacks. 3. **Explored the motives and characteristics of users using companion chatbots**. 4. **Provided suggestions for designing more effective and ethically responsible AI companions** to enhance users' mental health and social connections. By answering these questions, the research hopes to provide a more detailed understanding of AI companions in the field of human - computer interaction, guide technology development, and ensure that these tools can truly enhance human well - being and social connections.