Krishna P. B.,Adithya P S,Titus K. Mathew
Abstract:The emergent space paradigm is a unique way to understand the universe's expansion. In this paradigm, as proposed by Padmanabhan in the context of Einstein's gravity the expansion of the universe is driven by the difference between the degrees of freedom on the horizon surface and that within the bulk enclosed by the horizon. This principle called the law of emergence, has been extended to more general gravity theories like Gauss-Bonnet and Lovelock gravity. We derive the law of emergence for braneword models of gravity, starting from the more fundamental and well established principle, the first law of thermodynamics. More specifically, we derive the law of emergence in the context of RS II braneworld, warped DGP model and Gauss-Bonnet braneworld. The significance of the braneworld theory is that the observable universe could be a 3+1 surface or brane embedded in 3+1+d dimensional bulk spacetime. We further compared the derived law with the one proposed by Sheykhi for braneworld models. Our results strongly suggests that the unified first law of thermodynamics is the backbone of the law of emergence.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how to derive the law of emergence of cosmic space in the braneworld gravitational model starting from the first law of thermodynamics. Specifically, the authors are concerned with whether the expansion of the universe can be driven by the difference in degrees of freedom between the horizon surface and the internal volume in three different braneworld models, namely the RS II braneworld, the warped DGP model, and the Gauss - Bonnet braneworld, and whether this process can be described in the form of the first law of thermodynamics.
### Background of the Paper
- **The Relationship between Thermodynamics and Gravity**: Since Bekenstein and Hawking discovered that black holes have entropy and temperature, people have begun to explore the connection between gravity and thermodynamics. Jacobson et al. further proposed the possibility of deriving Einstein's field equations from a thermodynamic perspective.
- **Emergence of Cosmic Space**: Padmanabhan proposed that the expansion of cosmic space can be regarded as an "emergence" phenomenon, that is, the expansion of the universe is driven by the difference in degrees of freedom between the horizon surface (Nsurf) and the interior of the horizon (Nbulk).
- **Braneworld Theory**: The braneworld theory holds that the observable universe may be a 3 + 1 - dimensional brane embedded in a higher - dimensional spacetime. This theory provides a new perspective for understanding the properties of the universe, especially in explaining dark energy and the accelerated expansion of the universe.
### Research Objectives
- **Deriving the Emergence Law from the First Law of Thermodynamics**: The authors hope to prove that for different braneworld models, the law of emergence of cosmic space can be derived from the first law of thermodynamics, rather than just being proposed as a hypothesis.
- **Verifying the Consistency of the Emergence Law**: By comparing the derived emergence law with the previously proposed hypothesis form, verify its consistency and rationality.
### Main Contributions
- **RS II Braneworld Model**: Starting from the first law of thermodynamics, the authors derived the law of emergence of cosmic space in the RS II braneworld model and compared it with the hypothesis form proposed by Sheykhi et al., and the results are consistent.
- **Warped DGP Model**: Similarly, the authors also successfully derived the law of emergence of cosmic space in the warped DGP model and verified its consistency with the hypothesis form.
- **Gauss - Bonnet Braneworld Model**: In the Gauss - Bonnet braneworld model, the authors once again started from the first law of thermodynamics, derived the law of emergence of cosmic space, and verified its consistency with the hypothesis form.
### Conclusion
By deriving the law of emergence of cosmic space from the first law of thermodynamics in different braneworld models, the authors have proved the consistency and rationality of this law in these models. This not only provides a new perspective for understanding the expansion of the universe but also further consolidates the position of the first law of thermodynamics as a fundamental principle in cosmology.
### Formula Summary
- **Unified First Law**:
\[
dE = TdS+WdV
\]
where \(E\) is the horizon energy, \(T\) is the temperature of the horizon, \(S\) is the entropy of the horizon, \(W\) is the work density, and \(V\) is the volume.
- **Horizon Entropy**:
- RS II Braneworld Model:
\[
S=\frac{(n - 1)l\Omega_{n - 1}}{2G_{n+1}}\int_{0}^{\tilde{r}_A}\tilde{r}_A^{n - 2}\sqrt{\tilde{r}_A^{2}+l^{2}}\,d\tilde{r}_A
\]
- Warped DGP Model:
\[
S=(n - 1)\Omega_{n - 1}\int_{0}^{\tilde{r}_A}\left(\frac{(n - 2)\tilde{r}_A^{n - 3}}{4G_n}+\frac{l}{2G_{n+1}}+\tilde{r}_A^{n - 2}\sqrt{\tilde{r}_A^{2}+l^{2}}\right)d\tilde{r}_A
\]
- Gauss