Distribution-Aware Compensation Design for Sustainable Data Rights in Machine Learning

Jiaqi Shao,Tao Lin,Bing Luo
2024-10-24
Abstract:Modern distributed learning systems face a critical challenge when clients request the removal of their data influence from trained models, as this process can significantly destabilize system performance and affect remaining participants. We propose an innovative mechanism that views this challenge through the lens of game theory, establishing a leader-follower framework where a central coordinator provides strategic incentives to maintain system stability during data removal operations. Our approach quantifies the ripple effects of data removal through a comprehensive analytical model that captures both system-wide and participant-specific impacts. We establish mathematical foundations for measuring participant utility and system outcomes, revealing critical insights into how data diversity influences both individual decisions and overall system stability. The framework incorporates a computationally efficient solution method that addresses the inherent complexity of optimizing participant interactions and resource allocation.
Computer Science and Game Theory,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problems of system performance instability and affected parties in modern distributed learning systems when clients request the removal of the influence of their data from the trained model. Specifically, the paper mainly focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Impact of data removal on system performance**: When some participants request the removal of the influence of their data, the underlying data distribution of the system changes, which may lead to a significant decline in the performance of the model in different fields and tasks. 2. **Imbalance of participant incentives**: The impact of model updates on different participants varies greatly, resulting in a complex and unbalanced incentive mechanism for system participation. 3. **Complexity of participation decisions**: Participants' decisions depend not only on compensation proposals but also on expected performance results. The interaction between these factors makes participation decisions more complex. To solve the above problems, the paper proposes an innovative mechanism based on game theory. By establishing a leader - follower framework (Stackelberg game), the central coordinator provides strategic incentives to maintain the stability of the system during data removal operations. The main contributions of this mechanism include: - **Dynamic compensation modeling**: A complex two - stage decision - making process is implemented, and the coordinator considers the immediate and long - term stability impacts when designing the compensation strategy. - **Distribution - aware analysis**: New mathematical tools are provided to quantify how data distribution changes affect the performance indicators of the system as a whole and individual participants. - **Solvable optimization method**: A method for transforming complex non - convex compensation problems into computationally feasible optimization formulas is developed. Through these innovations, the paper aims to improve the stability and fairness of distributed learning systems while ensuring the effective implementation of privacy protection regulations (such as CCPA and GDPR).