Exploring the Role of Network Centrality in Player Selection: A Case Study of Pakistan Super League

Abeer Khan,Maria Hunaid Samiwala,Abeeha Zawar,Muhammad Qasim Pasta,Shah Jamal Alam
2024-10-18
Abstract:Cricket, a popular bat-and-ball game in South Asia, is played between two 11-player teams. The Pakistan Super League (PSL) is a commercial T20 domestic league comprised of six franchise-owned teams, where player selection is competitive. In this study, an existing role-based ranking structure is assessed that evaluates player performance in the context of team belongingness to generate optimal Pakistan cricket teams for international tournaments. The underlying assumption is that since cricket is fundamentally a team sport, the performance of players compared to their peers plays a crucial role in their selection. To accomplish this, a network is generated using ball-by-ball data from previous PSL matches (2016-2022), and social network analysis (SNA) techniques such as centrality and clustering coefficient measures, are employed to quantify the level of belongingness among Pakistani cricket players within the PSL network. Characteristic network models, such as the Erdös-Rényi, Watts-Strogatz, and Barabási-Albert models are utilized to gain insights into the small-world properties of the network. By ranking players using centrality and clustering coefficient metrics, four teams are formulated, and these teams are subsequently compared to the official squad selected by the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) for the recent ICC Men's T20 World Cup in 2022. This evaluation sheds light on the allegations of nepotism and favoritism in team formations that have been attributed to the PCB over the years. Based on our findings, out of the 18 players in the World Cup squad, 11 were included in the teams we formed. While most of the 7 players who were not included in our teams were still selected for the ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2022, they ranked highly in our rankings, suggesting their potential and competence.
Social and Information Networks
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to evaluate and select the best cricket players in the Pakistan Super League (PSL) through network centrality and Social Network Analysis (SNA) techniques in order to form an optimized national team. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Evaluate the existing role - based ranking structure**: The study evaluates an existing role - based ranking structure that assesses player performance in the context of team affiliation to generate the optimal Pakistani cricket team for international events. 2. **Quantify players' sense of belonging**: By using ball - by - ball data from PSL matches from 2016 to 2022, construct a network and use Social Network Analysis techniques (such as centrality and clustering coefficient measures) to quantify the sense of belonging of Pakistani cricket players in the network. 3. **Test accusations of nepotism and favoritism**: By comparing with the official team selected by the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) for the 2022 ICC Men's T20 World Cup, assess whether the selected players are affected by nepotism or favoritism. 4. **Provide a transparent and fair basis for player selection**: The research results can provide valuable insights for PCB stakeholders and managers, helping them make more informed decisions in future competitions and ensuring the transparency and fairness of the player selection process. ### Specific methods - **Data sources**: Obtain ball - by - ball data of PSL from 2016 to 2022 from Cricsheet. - **Network construction**: Represent each player as a node in the network, and the interactions between players as edges, with the weight determined by the proportion of co - matches. - **Network analysis**: Use Erdős - Rényi, Watts - Strogatz and Barabási - Albert models for comparison to analyze the small - world characteristics of the network. - **Centrality measures**: Calculate degree centrality, betweenness centrality and closeness centrality, as well as the local clustering coefficient to quantify the importance of players in the network. - **Team formation**: Rank players according to centrality and clustering coefficient indicators to form four teams and compare them with the official team. ### Main findings - **Network characteristics**: The PSL network exhibits highly interconnected small - world characteristics, with an average path length of only 2.16. - **Centrality analysis**: Players with high centrality play a crucial role in the network and influence the performance of other players. - **Team comparison**: Among the four teams formed, 11 players coincide with the official team, indicating that the network - analysis - based method has a certain degree of effectiveness. Through these analyses, the research not only provides a new perspective for understanding team dynamics in cricket but also provides a scientific basis for improving the player selection process.