What Reference Frames Teach Us. Part I: About Symmetry Principles and Observability

Nicola Bamonti,Henrique Gomes

2024-10-16

Abstract:This paper is an exploration of the nuanced realm of reference frames within the framework of General Relativity. Our analysis exposes a violation of Earman's SP1 principle in scenarios involving fields that are dynamically uncoupled, a common assumption for reference frames. Unlike other violations, we cannot foreclose it by eliminating background spacetime structure. Our analysis also leads us to challenge the conventional notion of partial observables as quantities that are associated with a measuring instrument and expressed within a coordinate system. Instead, we argue that a partial observable is inherently relational, even if gauge-variant, and needs dynamical coupling with other partial observables to form a bona-fide, gauge-invariant complete observables. This perspective allows us to distinguish between being relational and being gauge-invariant, two properties that are often conflated.

History and Philosophy of Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore the complexity of reference frames within the framework of general relativity, with particular attention to the principles of symmetry and the concept of observability. Specifically, the paper mainly addresses the following issues:

1. **The Failure of Earman's SP1 Principle in the Scenario of Dynamically Decoupled Fields**:
- The paper points out that in cases involving dynamically decoupled fields, Earman's SP1 principle (i.e., any dynamical symmetry is a spacetime symmetry) fails. This failure cannot be avoided by eliminating the background spacetime structure.
- By redefining dynamical symmetry (DS) and introducing two independent dynamical fields \(\Theta\) and \(\Psi\), the author shows that in the case where these fields are dynamically decoupled, the SP1 principle can be violated.

2. **Challenges to the Concept of Partial Observables**:
- Traditionally, partial observables are considered as quantities related to measuring instruments and expressed in coordinate systems. However, the paper proposes that partial observables are essentially relational. Even if they are gauge - variant, they need to be dynamically coupled with other partial observables to form a complete, gauge - invariant observable.
- The author emphasizes that relationality and gauge invariance are two properties that are often confused, but they are actually different concepts.

### Formula Explanation

- **Relationality of Partial Observables**:
- If two partial observables \(\phi_1\) and \(\phi_2\) are relational, then they remain invariant under any smooth transformation \(d\in\text{Diff}(M)\):
\[
\phi_2(\phi_1)\equiv d^*\phi_2(d^*\phi_1),\quad\forall d\in\text{Diff}(M)
\]
- This formula shows that the relationship between two partial observables remains invariant under smooth transformations.

- **Dynamical Symmetry**:
- The definition of dynamical symmetry \(d, f\in G_D\subseteq\text{Diff}(M)\times\text{Diff}(M)\) is as follows:
\[
\langle M,\Theta,\Psi\rangle\text{ is DPM}\iff\langle M,d^*\Theta,f^*\Psi\rangle\text{ is DPM}
\]
- This definition allows different dynamical fields to maintain the properties of solutions under different transformations.

### Conclusion

Through in - depth analysis of reference frames and symmetry principles, the paper reveals the challenges posed by the existence of dynamically decoupled fields in general relativity to traditional symmetry principles. At the same time, the paper redefines the concept of partial observables, emphasizes the difference between relationality and gauge invariance, and provides a new perspective for understanding observables in general relativity.