Towards a Healthy AI Tradition: Lessons from Biology and Biomedical Science

Simon Kasif
2024-10-15
Abstract:AI is a magnificent field that directly and profoundly touches on numerous disciplines ranging from philosophy, computer science, engineering, mathematics, decision and data science and economics, to cognitive science, neuroscience and more. The number of applications and impact of AI is second to none and the potential of AI to broadly impact future science developments is particularly thrilling. While attempts to understand knowledge, reasoning, cognition and learning go back centuries, AI remains a relatively new field. In part due to the fact it has so many wide-ranging overlaps with other disparate fields it appears to have trouble developing a robust identity and culture. Here we suggest that contrasting the fast-moving AI culture to biological and biomedical sciences is both insightful and useful way to inaugurate a healthy tradition needed to envision and manage our ascent to AGI and beyond (independent of the AI Platforms used). The co-evolution of AI and Biomedical Science offers many benefits to both fields. In a previous perspective, we suggested that biomedical laboratories or centers can usefully embrace logistic traditions in AI labs that will allow them to be highly collaborative, improve the reproducibility of research, reduce risk aversion and produce faster mentorship pathways for PhDs and fellows. This perspective focuses on the benefits to AI by adapting features of biomedical science at higher, primarily cultural levels.
Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore how to establish a healthy AI research tradition to address the current challenges and risks in the AI field. Specifically, by comparing the culture and practice of biology and biomedical sciences, the author proposes the following problems and solutions: 1. **Culture and Identity in the AI Field**: - As a relatively new field, AI, due to its extensive cross - disciplinary nature, has difficulty forming a solid identity and culture. The author suggests drawing on the culture of biology and biomedical sciences to help the AI field establish a healthy research tradition. 2. **AI Safety and Ethical Issues**: - With the rapid development of AI technology, safety and ethical issues are becoming increasingly important. The author emphasizes the importance of balancing benefits and risks in AI development and points out that, like in the biomedical field, a rigorous method is needed to verify and manage AI systems. 3. **Inter - disciplinary Cooperation and Knowledge Integration**: - The author believes that the development of AI requires inter - disciplinary cooperation, especially in understanding cognition, learning, and reasoning. By drawing on successful experiences in biomedicine, cooperation among different AI sub - fields can be promoted, thus better solving complex problems. 4. **Respect and Inheritance of History and Tradition**: - The paper calls for more recognition and respect for the achievements in AI history, avoiding excessive criticism and ignoring AI's actual contributions. The author believes that AI's successes are often absorbed by other fields, leading to an underestimation of its contributions. Therefore, a tradition of gratitude and recognition should be established to inspire future innovation and development. 5. **Selection and Development of AI Platforms**: - The paper discusses the debates among different AI platforms (such as neural networks, symbolic logic, probability models, etc.) and suggests adopting a more open and inclusive attitude, encouraging cooperation and complementarity among different methods. The author believes that the currently dominant deep - learning method may be due to limitations in computing resources and technical conditions, and new breakthrough methods may emerge in the future. 6. **Education and Talent Cultivation**: - The author emphasizes the importance of AI education, especially in cultivating the next - generation of researchers with an inter - disciplinary background and ethical awareness. By drawing on the experience of biomedical education, a better education model can be provided for the AI field. 7. **Public Participation and Social Responsibility**: - Finally, the author proposes that the public can be involved in AI safety testing and verification through citizen science, ensuring that the application of AI technology meets the interests and needs of society. In summary, this paper attempts to establish a healthier, more robust, and sustainable research tradition in the AI field by comparing the culture and practice of biology and biomedical sciences, in order to meet current and future challenges.