Comment on "A try for dark energy in quantum field theory: The vacuum energy of neutrino field"

James M. Cline
2024-10-17
Abstract:It was recently suggested (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2410.06604" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.06604">arXiv:2410.06604</a>) that the small value of the dark energy of the universe could be explained in terms of the scale of neutrino masses through a simple quantum field theoretic mechanism. I clarify that the quantity computed is only a threshold correction to the vacuum energy at the low $m_\nu$ scale, and therefore cannot explain the magnitude of the vacuum energy.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to **the small value of the cosmic dark energy density**, and it tries to explain this phenomenon through the scale of neutrino mass. Specifically, the paper explores how to use the mechanism of quantum field theory to link the cosmic dark energy density with the mass of neutrinos. According to the standard model, the mass of neutrinos is very small (about \( m_\nu \sim 0.01 \, \text{eV} \)). And the dark energy density (i.e., the vacuum energy density) is also very small in observation. The author proposes a hypothesis: by calculating the vacuum energy contribution of the neutrino field, it may be possible to explain the small value of the observed dark energy density. However, James M. Cline pointed out in his comment that this method has limitations. He emphasized that the quantity calculated in the paper is actually only a threshold correction term of the vacuum energy at the low - energy scale \( m_\nu \), and it cannot fully explain the total magnitude of the vacuum energy. In addition, Cline raised some doubts, such as: 1. **Why choose a specific renormalization scale \( \mu \)**: The paper does not clearly explain why a certain \( \mu \) value is chosen. 2. **Ignoring the contributions of other standard model particles**: Besides neutrinos, other particles may also have similar contributions to the vacuum energy, but these contributions are not considered in the paper. Therefore, although this is an interesting attempt, it is still not sufficient to fully explain the origin of dark energy and the problem of the small value of its observed value at present. ### Summary The core problem of the paper is to attempt to explain the small - value problem of cosmic dark energy through the quantum field theory mechanism of neutrino mass, but its method has theoretical deficiencies and limitations, especially in dealing with threshold corrections and the choice of renormalization scale.