Towards an ab initio theory of high-temperature superconductors: a study of multilayer cuprates

Benjamin Bacq-Labreuil,Benjamin Lacasse,André-Marie S. Tremblay,David Sénéchal,Kristjan Haule
2024-10-14
Abstract:Significant progress towards a theory of high-temperature superconductivity in cuprates has been achieved via the study of effective one- and three-band Hubbard models. Nevertheless, material-specific predictions, while essential for constructing a comprehensive theory, remain challenging due to the complex relationship between real materials and the parameters of the effective models. By combining cluster dynamical mean-field theory and density functional theory in a charge-self-consistent manner, here we show that the goal of material-specific predictions for high-temperature superconductors from first principles is within reach. We take on the challenge of explaining the remarkable physics of multilayer cuprates by focusing on the two representative Ca$_{(1+n)}$Cu$_{n}$O$_{2n}$Cl$_2$ and HgBa$_2$Ca$_{(n-1)}$Cu$_n$O$_{(2n+2)}$ families. We shed light on the microscopic origin of many salient features of multilayer cuprates, in particular the $n$-dependence of their superconducting properties. The maximum of $T_c$ for the tri-layer compounds is explained by an intertwined analysis of the charge-transfer gap, superexchange $J$, and inhomogeneous doping between the CuO$_{2}$ planes. We highlight the existence of a minimal doping (4\%) required for superconductivity to emerge. We capture material-specific properties such as the larger propensity of HgBa$_2$Ca$_{(n-1)}$Cu$_n$O$_{(2n+2)}$ to superconduct compared with Ca$_{(1+n)}$Cu$_{n}$O$_{2n}$Cl$_2$. We also find the coexistence of arcs and pockets observed with photoemission, the charge redistribution between copper and oxygen, and the link to the pseudogap. Our work establishes a framework for comprehensive studies of cuprates, enables detailed comparisons with experiment, and, through its \emph{ab initio} settings, unlocks opportunities for theoretical material design of high-temperature superconductors.
Strongly Correlated Electrons,Superconductivity
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve The paper aims to solve the problem of theoretical prediction of high - temperature superconductors (especially multi - layer cuprates). Although significant progress has been made in describing high - temperature superconductors by studying effective single - band and three - band Hubbard models, prediction for specific materials remains challenging. This is because the relationship between actual materials and effective model parameters is very complex. By combining cluster dynamical mean - field theory (CDMFT) and density functional theory (DFT) in a charge - self - consistent manner, the paper shows the possibility of making material - specific predictions from first principles. ### Specific problems and methods 1. **Challenges in material - specific prediction**: - The complexity of high - temperature superconductors makes it difficult to parameterize effective models. - The relationship between experimental materials and model parameters is not clear, resulting in a not - so - tight connection between theory and experiment. 2. **Methodological innovation**: - **Combining CDMFT and DFT**: By combining CDMFT with DFT, the authors propose a new framework that can make material - specific predictions based on first principles. - **Charge self - consistency**: This method takes into account the feedback effect of strong correlations on the DFT charge density, thus describing the electronic structure and superconducting properties of materials more accurately. - **Computational efficiency**: Using the exact diagonalization (ED) solver significantly reduces the computational cost, making the study of complex materials possible. 3. **Research objects**: - The authors selected two representative multi - layer cuprate families: Ca\(_{1 + n}\)Cu\(_n\)O\(_{2n}\)Cl\(_2\) and HgBa\(_2\)Ca\(_{n - 1}\)Cu\(_n\)O\(_{2n + 2}\). - They focused on the physical properties of these compounds from single - layer to five - layer, especially the \(n\)-dependence of their superconducting transition temperature \(T_c\). 4. **Main findings**: - **\(n\)-dependence of \(T_c\)**: The growth of \(T_c\) from single - layer to three - layer compounds is explained by reducing the charge transfer gap (CTG) and increasing the superexchange interaction \(J\). - **Superconductivity in inner planes**: For compounds with \(n\geq4\), superconductivity disappears in these planes due to insufficient effective hole doping in the inner planes. - **Lowest doping threshold**: It is revealed that the minimum doping amount required for superconductivity to occur is approximately 4%. ### Conclusion The paper establishes a comprehensive framework for studying high - temperature superconducting cuprates, enables a detailed comparison of experimental results, and, through its first - principles - based method, opens up new opportunities for the theoretical design of high - temperature superconducting materials.