Abstract:Critical infrastructures provide essential services for our modern society. Large-scale natural hazards, such as floods or storms, can disrupt multiple critical infrastructures at once. In addition, a localized failure of one service can trigger a cascade of failures of other dependent services. This makes it challenging to anticipate and prepare adequately for direct and indirect consequences of such events. Existing methods that are spatially explicit and consider service dependencies currently lack practicality, as they require large amounts of data. To address this gap, we propose a novel method called DISruptionMap which analyzes complex disruptions to critical infrastructure services. The proposed method combines i) spatial service models to assess direct service disruptions with ii) a service dependency model to assess indirect (cascading) service disruptions. A fault tree-based approach is implemented, resulting in a significant decrease in the information required to set up the service dependency model. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in a case study examining the impact of an extreme flood on health, transport, and power services in Cologne, Germany.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the evaluation of service disruptions of Critical Infrastructures (CIs) in large - scale disaster scenarios, especially how these disruptions generate cascading effects through the dependencies between different services. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points: 1. **Evaluation of direct and indirect service disruptions**: Existing methods have made certain progress in evaluating the direct impacts of natural disasters on critical infrastructures, but most of them lack consideration of service dependencies, which makes it difficult to comprehensively evaluate the impacts of indirect (cascading) service disruptions. The method proposed in the paper aims to evaluate both direct and indirect service disruptions simultaneously. 2. **Reducing data requirements**: Existing methods usually require a large amount of data to establish spatial models and service - dependency models, which may be difficult to achieve in practical applications. The method proposed in the paper reduces the amount of required data by using Bayesian Networks (BN), making the method more practical. 3. **Effectively integrating expert knowledge**: Due to the scarcity of historical data, expert knowledge plays an important role in evaluating the dependencies and cascading effects of critical infrastructures. The method proposed in the paper can effectively integrate expert knowledge while maintaining the simplicity of the model. 4. **Providing decision - support tools**: By combining Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and Bayesian Networks, the method proposed in the paper can generate an interactive dashboard to help decision - makers quickly understand and analyze service disruption situations in large - scale disaster scenarios, thus providing support for the planning and training of disaster response measures. ### Main contributions of the paper - **DISruptionMap method**: This is a new method for evaluating direct and indirect disruptions of critical infrastructure services in large - scale disaster scenarios. This method combines GIS spatial models and service - dependency models based on Bayesian Networks, and can effectively integrate expert knowledge while reducing data requirements. - **Case study**: The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the DISruptionMap method through a case study of an extreme flood scenario in Cologne, Germany. This case study focuses on analyzing the availability of hospital emergency care services, taking into account factors such as power supply and road accessibility. - **Result visualization**: The paper has developed an interactive dashboard that can intuitively display service disruption situations, helping decision - makers quickly obtain key information. ### Conclusion The DISruptionMap method proposed in the paper provides a new and practical tool for evaluating critical infrastructure service disruptions in large - scale disaster scenarios. By combining GIS and Bayesian Networks, this method can not only evaluate direct service disruptions, but also effectively evaluate indirect cascading effects, providing strong support for disaster management and emergency response.

Dependent Infrastructure Service Disruption Mapping (DISruptionMap): A Method to Assess Cascading Service Disruptions in Disaster Scenarios

Battle of Postdisaster Response and Restoration

Interdependent effects of critical infrastructure systems under different types of disruptions

Post-disaster Restoration Planning of Interdependent Infrastructure Systems: A Framework to Balance Social and Economic Impacts

Mapping Disruption Sources in the Power Grid and Implications for Resilience

The Impact of Natural Disasters on Critical Infrastructures: A Domino Effect-based Study

Measuring accessibility to public services and infrastructure criticality for disasters risk management

Modeling and solving cascading failures across interdependent infrastructure systems

A Bayesian Approach to Reconstructing Interdependent Infrastructure Networks from Cascading Failures

The disruption transport model: computing user delays resulting from infrastructure failures for multi-modal passenger & freight traffic

InfraRisk: An Open-Source Simulation Platform for Asset-Level Resilience Analysis in Interconnected Infrastructure Networks

Understanding the impact of cascade effects of natural disasters on disaster relief operations

A New Methodology to Model Interdependency of Critical Infrastructure Systems During Hurricane Sandy’s Event

A Conceptual Framework for Modeling Critical Infrastructure Interdependency: Using a Multilayer Directed Network Model and Targeted Attack-Based Resilience Analysis

Modeling interdependencies of critical infrastructures after hurricane Sandy

Generation of harmonised pluvial flood hazard maps through decentralised analytics

The Physical Infrastructure Dimension Taking into Account Interdependencies

Modeling flood induced interdependencies among hydroelectricity generating infrastructures

Geographic Hotspots of Critical National Infrastructure

Disaster Economics and Networked Transportation Infrastructures: Status Quo and a Multi-disciplinary Framework to Estimate Economic Losses.

Evaluating the societal impact of disaster-driven infrastructure disruptions: A water analysis perspective