Research Landscape of the novel emerging field of Cryptoeconomics

Alican Alasik,Nihan Yildirim

2024-10-04

Abstract:A bibliometric literature analysis was conducted to illuminate the evolving and rapidly expanding literature in the field of cryptoeconomics. This analysis presented the emerging field's intellectual, social, and conceptual structure. The intellectual structure, characterized by schools of thought, emerged through a common citation analysis. The social structure revealed collaborations among researchers, identified through a co-authorship analysis. Network analysis highlighted collaborative communities facilitating innovation and knowledge exchange within the field. The conceptual structure was enlightened by analyzing common terms occurring in titles, author keywords, abstracts, and the publication itself. This bibliometric analysis of the rapidly advancing field of cryptoeconomics serves as a foundational resource, providing insights into research productivity and emerging trends. It contributes to a deeper understanding of the field, offering valuable information on research patterns and trends. Furthermore, this analysis empowers researchers, policymakers, and industry sectors to make informed decisions, establish collaborations, and navigate the dynamic and evolving landscape of the cryptoeconomics field.

Social and Information Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to clarify the research status of the emerging and rapidly expanding field of cryptoeconomics through bibliometric analysis. Specifically, this study aims to reveal three main structures in the field of cryptoeconomics: intellectual structure, social structure, and conceptual structure. The specific objectives of these structures are as follows:

1. **Intellectual Structure**:
- Through co - citation analysis, identify frequently cited articles, influential authors, and the evolution of core topics in the field of cryptoeconomics.
- Reveal the multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary nature of cryptoeconomics research, especially its institutional characteristics.
- Clarify the theoretical basis that underpins institutional change in cryptoeconomics.

2. **Social Structure**:
- Through co - authorship analysis, explore research cooperation patterns.
- Reveal cooperation communities that promote innovation and knowledge exchange, and show the convergence between different disciplines.
- Analyze international cooperation networks, point out the current relative weakness of international cooperation, and suggest that future research should strengthen international cooperation to promote the development of the field.

3. **Conceptual Structure**:
- Using co - word analysis, reveal the common keywords and concepts in article titles and abstracts, providing insights into the dominant topics and ideas in the field.
- Through different co - occurrence networks, discover hidden relationships and core concepts, although these concepts may be used in a broader framework.

Overall, through in - depth analysis of these three structures, this paper provides a valuable resource for researchers, policymakers, and industry practitioners, helping them better understand the research dynamics and trends in the field of cryptoeconomics, so as to make informed decisions, establish cooperation relationships, and navigate this rapidly developing field.

### Key Formulas

- **Co - citation Matrix**:
\[
B_{\text{co - citation}} = A\times A'
\]
where \( A \) is the document × cited reference matrix, and the element \( b_{ij} \) in \( B_{\text{co - citation}} \) represents the number of co - citations between documents \( i \) and \( j \).

- **Co - authorship Matrix**:
\[
B_{\text{co - author}} = A\times A'
\]
where \( A \) is the document × author matrix, and the element \( b_{ij} \) in \( B_{\text{co - author}} \) represents the number of collaborations between authors \( i \) and \( j \).

- **Co - word Matrix**:
\[
B_{\text{co - word}} = A\times A'
\]
where \( A \) is the document × vocabulary matrix, and the vocabulary can be author - selected keywords, additional keywords, or terms extracted from titles and abstracts, and the element \( b_{ij} \) in \( B_{\text{co - word}} \) represents the number of co - occurrences between words \( i \) and \( j \).

These formulas are used to construct various network graphs to visualize and analyze the structures and dynamics in the field of cryptoeconomics.