Cross-Domain Comparative Analysis of Digital Twins and Universalised Solutions

Guanyu Xiong,Yan Gao,Haijiang Li

2024-10-03

Abstract:Digitalisation is one of the main drivers of most economic sectors nowadays and the digital twin, as a reification of digitalisation for complex systems has attracted much attention from both academics and industry. There have been studies focusing on digital twins in a specific sector while there are few exercising insightful comparisons of digital twins from different domains. Considering the digital twinning is a cross-domain transformation, it is beneficial to establish the principles of universality and variation that can explain similarities and differences in any digital twins. This paper first delivers a comparative analysis of digital twins in five domains through a six-dimensional characterisation framework. Then, by departing from the correlations among the domain-specific DT development, a cross-domain Digital Twin Platform-as-a-Service (DT-PaaS) is proposed to universalise the common process, tools and applications, meanwhile being inclusive of variations of every digital twin instance. As a centralised data, modeling and service platform, it is expected to break the barriers between domains by enabling the cross-domain digital twin data sharing, interoperability and development synergy and tackle some complex global challenges such as climate challenge, net zero, pandemics, etc.

Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Comparative analysis of cross - domain Digital Twin (DT) and establishment of general - purpose solutions**. Specifically, the paper aims to fill the gap in in - depth comparative analysis of digital twins in different domains in existing research and propose a framework and service platform that can be generalized to handle digital twins in different domains.

### Decomposition of main problems:

1. **Insufficient comparative analysis of cross - domain digital twins**:
- Most of the existing research focuses on digital twin applications in specific domains and lacks in - depth cross - domain comparison.
- Although some research has been carried out for comparison, it is usually based on an advanced domain (such as manufacturing) as a reference, which may lead to the inability to fully reveal the commonalities and differences between different domains.

2. **Lack of a general - purpose comparison framework**:
- At present, there is no clear standard or framework for comparing digital twins in different domains, making it difficult to systematically understand their commonalities and differences.
- It is necessary to establish a general - purpose framework applicable to all domains to ensure the accuracy and consistency of comparison.

3. **How to achieve cross - domain collaborative development**:
- Digital twins in different domains have their own characteristics and requirements in the development process, and a method needs to be found to unify these characteristics while retaining their respective features.
- A cross - domain Digital Twin - Platform - as - a - Service (DT - PaaS) is proposed, aiming to break down the barriers between domains and promote data sharing, interoperability and development collaboration.

### Core objectives of the paper:

- **Establish a comparison framework for cross - domain digital twins**: Through a six - dimensional feature framework, conduct a detailed comparison of digital twins in five different domains to identify commonalities and differences.
- **Propose a cross - domain general - purpose solution**: Based on the comparison results, design and propose a cross - domain Digital Twin - Platform - as - a - Service (DT - PaaS) to achieve cross - domain collaborative development and resource sharing.
- **Address complex global challenges**: It is expected that through this cross - domain collaborative platform, some complex global problems such as climate change, carbon neutrality, and pandemics can be solved.

### Overview of methodology:

1. **Select representative domains**: Through literature classification and a three - sector model, five representative domains are selected for comparison.
2. **Construct a six - dimensional comparison framework**: From the conceptual and implementation levels, a comparison framework covering six dimensions is established, including twin objects, twin purposes, system architectures, etc.
3. **Extract and analyze features**: According to the selected domains, extract the features of typical digital twin instances and match them with the dimensions in the comparison framework.
4. **Summarize commonalities and differences**: Through the thematic analysis method, summarize the similarities and differences of digital twins in different domains.
5. **Propose a general - purpose solution**: Based on the above analysis, design a cross - domain Digital Twin - Platform - as - a - Service (DT - PaaS) to achieve cross - domain collaborative development.

Through these steps, the paper not only fills the gap in cross - domain digital twin comparative analysis but also provides theoretical basis and technical support for future cross - domain digital twin applications.