Revisiting Digital Twins: Origins, Fundamentals and Practices

Jiehan Zhou,Shouhua Zhang,Mu Gu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.12867

2022-03-24

Abstract:The Digital Twins (DT) has quickly become a hot topic since it was proposed. It not only appears in all kinds of commercial propaganda, but also is widely quoted by academic circles. However, there are misstatements and misuse of the term DT in business and academy. This paper revisits Digital Twins and defines it to be a more advanced system/product/service modelling and simulation environment that combines the most modern Information Communication Technology (ICTs) and engineering mechanisms digitization, and characterized by system/product/service life cycle management, physically geometric visualization, real-time sensing and measurement of system operating conditions, predictability of system performance/safety/lifespan, complete engineering mechanisms-based simulations. The idea of Digital Twins originates from modelling and simulation practices of engineering informatization, including Virtual Manufacturing (VM), Model Predictive Control (MPC), and Building Information Model (BIM). Based on the two-element VM model, we propose a three-element model to represent Digital Twins. Digital Twins does not have its own unique technical characteristics; the existing practices of Digital Twins are extensions of the engineering informatization embracing modern ICTs. These insights clarify the origin of Digital Twins and its technical essentials.

Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science,Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the misuse and abuse of the concept of Digital Twins (DT) in the business and academic communities. Specifically:

1. **Confusion in Definition**: Since the concept of DT was proposed, although it has quickly become popular in commercial promotion and academic circles, its definition is rather chaotic. Different institutions and enterprises have different definitions of DT. This confusion has led to technological ambiguity and has even become more so in the emerging meta - universe entertainment.

2. **Controversy over Origin**: There is a controversy regarding the origin of DT. Some literatures wrongly believe that DT originated from the Mirrored Space Model (MSM) proposed by Michael Grieves. In fact, the concept of DT can be traced back to earlier research, such as the Virtual Manufacturing (VM) system proposed by Professor Iwata's team at Osaka University in 1993.

3. **Unclear Technological Essence**: Although DT has been widely used in the industrial and academic fields, its technological essence remains unclear. The paper attempts to re - define DT and clarify its technological features and application scope by reviewing the development history of DT.

To clarify these issues, the paper has carried out the following work:

- **Tracing the Origin of DT**: By consulting a large number of primary sources, it has corrected the statement that DT originated from MSM and pointed out that the concept of DT can be traced back to the VM system in 1993 at the earliest.

- **Re - defining DT**: DT is defined as an Advanced System Modelling and Simulation Environment (ASM&SE), emphasizing its features in system life - cycle management, physical geometry visualization, real - time sensing and measurement, system performance/safety/lifetime prediction, and simulation based on complete engineering mechanisms.

- **Proposing a Three - Element Model**: Based on the two - element model of VM, a three - element model of DT is proposed, namely the geometry, information, and engineering mechanisms of the actual system, in order to describe the composition of DT more comprehensively.

- **Analyzing DT Practices**: Through case studies, it has analyzed the current applications of DT in fields such as intelligent manufacturing, intelligent buildings, intelligent energy, and smart agriculture, and pointed out that most of these practices are extensions of traditional informatization and digitization and partly reflect the characteristics of DT.

In short, the paper aims to help researchers and practitioners better understand and apply DT by re - defining DT and its technological features and clarifying its origin and development history.