Abstract:Prophet inequality concerns a basic optimal stopping problem and states that simple threshold stopping policies -- i.e., accepting the first reward larger than a certain threshold -- can achieve tight $\frac{1}{2}$-approximation to the optimal prophet value. Motivated by its economic applications, this paper studies the robustness of this approximation to natural strategic manipulations in which each random reward is associated with a self-interested player who may selectively reveal his realized reward to the searcher in order to maximize his probability of being selected. We say a threshold policy is $\alpha$(-strategically)-robust if it (a) achieves the $\alpha$-approximation to the prophet value for strategic players; and (b) meanwhile remains a $\frac{1}{2}$-approximation in the standard non-strategic setting. Starting with a characterization of each player's optimal information revealing strategy, we demonstrate the intrinsic robustness of prophet inequalities to strategic reward signaling through the following results: (1) for arbitrary reward distributions, there is a threshold policy that is $\frac{1-\frac{1}{e}}{2}$-robust, and this ratio is tight; (2) for i.i.d. reward distributions, there is a threshold policy that is $\frac{1}{2}$-robust, which is tight for the setting; and (3) for log-concave (but non-identical) reward distributions, the $\frac{1}{2}$-robustness can also be achieved under certain regularity assumptions.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper The paper explores the robustness of the Prophet Inequality when faced with strategic reward signals. Specifically, the Prophet Inequality focuses on a fundamental optimal stopping problem, where a simple threshold stopping strategy (e.g., accepting the first reward greater than a certain threshold) can achieve a tight 1/2 approximation to the optimal prophet value. However, in practical applications, each random reward may be associated with a self-interested participant who may selectively reveal their realized reward to the searcher to maximize the probability of being chosen. Therefore, the paper investigates the robustness of the Prophet Inequality under such circumstances. ### Main Contributions 1. **Robustness under Arbitrary Reward Distributions**: - For arbitrary reward distributions, there exists a threshold strategy with a robustness of $1 - \frac{1}{e^2}$, and this ratio is tight. 2. **Robustness under Independent and Identically Distributed (IID) Rewards**: - For IID rewards, there exists a threshold strategy with a robustness of 1/2, which is also the best ratio under this setting. 3. **Robustness under Log-Concave Reward Distributions**: - Under certain regular conditions, for non-identically distributed but log-concave rewards, any threshold between the expected maximum value and the median of the highest reward can achieve a robustness of 1/2. ### Methods - **Optimal Information Revelation Strategy**: - Given any threshold stopping strategy, each participant's optimal information revelation strategy has a clear threshold structure. Specifically, there exists a reward threshold $t_i$ such that participant $i$ only needs to reveal $X_i \geq t_i$ or $X_i < t_i$. Moreover, $t_i$ satisfies $E[X_i | X_i \geq t_i] = T$. - **Simplified Model**: - Through the above optimal information revelation strategy, the original problem can be simplified to a problem of a binary support distribution $G_i$, where $G_i$ supports two realized values $T$ and $a_i$. ### Conclusion The paper demonstrates that the classic Prophet Inequality remains robust when faced with strategic reward signals. In particular, using the threshold $T_{KW}$ proposed by Kleinberg and Weinberg can achieve a robustness of $1 - \frac{1}{e^2}$ under arbitrary reward distributions, and this result is tight. For IID rewards, there exists a threshold strategy that can achieve a robustness of 1/2, which is also the best result. Additionally, for log-concave reward distributions, a robustness of 1/2 can also be achieved under certain conditions. These results provide an important theoretical foundation for understanding the performance of the Prophet Inequality in strategic environments.

Intrinsic Robustness of Prophet Inequality to Strategic Reward Signaling

Prophet Inequalities with Limited Information

Prophet secretary through blind strategies

Prophet Inequalities: Competing with the Top $\ell$ Items is Easy

Combinatorial Stationary Prophet Inequalities

IID Prophet Inequality with Random Horizon: Going Beyond Increasing Hazard Rates

The Prophet Inequality Can Be Solved Optimally with a Single Set of Samples

Prophet Secretary Against the Online Optimal

Prophet Inequalities via the Expected Competitive Ratio

Optimal Guarantees for Online Selection Over Time

Prophet Inequality with Correlated Arrival Probabilities, with Application to Two Sided Matchings

The Competition Complexity of Prophet Inequalities with Correlations

Prophet Inequalities with Cancellation Costs

Prophet Inequalities: Separating Random Order from Order Selection

Lookback Prophet Inequalities

Minimization I.I.D. Prophet Inequality via Extreme Value Theory: A Unified Approach

Oracle-Augmented Prophet Inequalities

Optimal single threshold stopping rules and sharp prophet inequalities

Prophet Inequality from Samples: Is the More the Merrier?

The IID Prophet Inequality with Limited Flexibility

New Prophet Inequalities via Poissonization and Sharding