New Prophet Inequalities via Poissonization and Sharding

Elfarouk Harb

2024-04-04

Abstract:This work introduces \emph{sharding} and \emph{Poissonization} as a unified framework for analyzing prophet inequalities. Sharding involves splitting a random variable into several independent random variables, shards, that collectively mimic the original variable's behavior. We combine this with Poissonization, where these shards are modeled using a Poisson distribution. Despite the simplicity of our framework, we improve the competitive ratio analysis of a dozen well studied prophet inequalities in the literature, some of which have been studied for decades. This includes the \textsc{Top-$1$-of-$k$} prophet inequality, prophet secretary inequality, and semi-online prophet inequality, among others. This approach not only refines the constants but also offers a more intuitive and streamlined analysis for many prophet inequalities in the literature. Furthermore, it simplifies proofs of several known results and may be of independent interest for other variants of the prophet inequality, such as order-selection.

Data Structures and Algorithms

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to address is the optimization of prophet inequalities in stopping theory. Specifically, the authors introduce a new framework—sharding and Poissonization—for analyzing and improving various prophet inequality problems. These problems include but are not limited to:

1. **Top-1-of-k Prophet Inequality**: In this model, the adversary can arrange the random variables \(X_1, \ldots, X_n\) in an adversarial manner, and the gambler can choose up to \(k \geq 2\) outcomes, with the final reward being the maximum of the chosen outcomes.

2. **Prophet Secretary Problem**: In this variant, the realizations of the random variables arrive in a randomly permuted order. The gambler needs to decide whether to accept the current value as the final reward or to continue waiting for the next value.

3. **Semi-Online Problem**: In this variant, the actual values of the random variables are hidden from the gambler, who can obtain information through adaptive queries and select the variable with the highest conditional expectation.

4. **Semi-Online Load Minimization Problem**: Similar to the semi-online problem, but each variable can be queried multiple times. The goal is to minimize the maximum number of queries for a single variable while achieving a near-optimal competitive ratio.

By introducing the methods of sharding and Poissonization, the authors not only simplify the proofs of known results but also improve the competitive ratios for several classic prophet inequality problems. For example, for the Top-1-of-2 model, the authors raise the lower bound from approximately 0.731 to 0.781 and lower the upper bound from 0.8 to approximately 0.794; for the Prophet Secretary Problem, they raise the lower bound from 0.669 to 0.6724; for the Semi-Online Problem, they raise the lower bound from 0.869 to 0.89; for the Semi-Online Load Minimization Problem, they improve the upper bound from \(O(\log n)\) to \(O(\log^* n)\).

In summary, the main contribution of this paper is providing a unified and powerful framework for analyzing and improving various prophet inequality problems, thereby simplifying the proof process and enhancing the competitive ratios.