Abstract:Nonlinear dynamics of runaway electron induced wave instabilities can significantly modify the runaway distribution critical to tokamak operations. Here we present the first-ever fully kinetic simulations of runaway-driven instabilities towards nonlinear saturation in a warm plasma as in tokamak start up. It is found that the slow-X modes grow an order of magnitude faster than the whistler modes, and they parametrically decay to produce whistlers much faster than those directly driven by runaways. These parent-daughter waves, as well as secondary and tertiary wave instabilities, initiate a chain of wave-particle resonances that strongly diffuse runaways to the backward direction. This reduces almost half of the current carried by high-energy runaways, over a time scale orders of magnitude faster than experimental shot duration. These results beyond quasilinear analysis may impact anisotropic energetic electrons broadly in laboratory, space and astrophysics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the wave instability caused by runaway electrons in tokamaks (a device used for nuclear fusion research) and its impact on the runaway electron distribution. Specifically, through the first full - kinetic simulation, the paper studies the development process of runaway - electron - driven instabilities towards nonlinear saturation, especially in a warm plasma environment, similar to the conditions during the tokamak startup phase.
### Main research questions:
1. **Wave instabilities triggered by runaway electrons**: Runaway electrons can be accelerated under the action of a strong electric field and can excite wave instabilities in the plasma. How do the nonlinear dynamics of these wave instabilities affect the distribution of runaway electrons?
2. **Relative growth rates of slow - X modes and whistler modes**: What are the relative growth rates of slow - X modes and whistler modes? Does the slow - X mode grow faster than the whistler mode?
3. **Wave - particle resonance chains**: How do these wave instabilities diffuse runaway electrons in the opposite direction through wave - particle resonance chains? What is the impact of this process on the runaway current?
4. **Nonlinear saturation mechanisms**: How do these wave instabilities reach a nonlinear saturation state? Can this process be accurately described by quasi - linear theory?
### Research background:
- **Hazards of runaway electrons**: Runaway electrons can cause serious damage to the plasma - facing components of tokamaks, especially during tokamak startup and major disruptions.
- **Experimental progress**: In recent years, through high - resolution measurement techniques (such as spatio - temporal energy - spectrum measurements of Bremsstrahlung hard X - ray emissions), researchers have been able to understand the distribution of runaway electrons in more detail.
- **Comparison between theory and simulation**: Experimental data provide an opportunity to verify theoretical predictions and simulation results, especially regarding the role of forward - propagating whistler waves.
### Research methods:
- **Full - kinetic simulation**: Using the particle - in - cell (PIC) simulation method, combined with a consistent runaway electron distribution obtained from a drift - kinetic solver, to study the development process of runaway - electron - self - driven instabilities towards nonlinear saturation.
- **Parameter settings**: The simulation uses typical tokamak startup parameters, including current density, electron density, temperature, magnetic field strength, etc.
### Main findings:
- **Growth rate of slow - X mode**: The growth rate of the slow - X mode is an order of magnitude higher than that of the whistler wave, and it quickly generates whistler waves through parametric decay.
- **Wave - particle resonance chains**: The slow - X mode and its sub - waves, through a series of wave - particle resonance chains, quickly diffuse runaway electrons in the opposite direction, significantly reducing the current carried by high - energy runaway electrons.
- **Nonlinear saturation**: These findings are beyond the scope of quasi - linear analysis and reveal secondary and tertiary wave instabilities caused by complex wave - wave interactions and runaway electron - wave interactions.
### Conclusions:
- **New physical picture**: The full - kinetic simulation reveals a brand - new physical picture, showing the complex wave - wave interactions caused by runaway electrons and the secondary and tertiary wave instabilities caused by runaway electron - wave interactions.
- **Application prospects**: These findings are not only of great significance for understanding the dynamics of runaway electrons in tokamaks but may also be widely applied to the evolution and transport problems of anisotropic high - energy electrons in laboratory, space, and astrophysics.