Study of the asymptotic motion of a sporting projectile taking into account the Magnus force

Peter Chudinov
2024-10-02
Abstract:A classic problem of the motion of a projectile thrown at an angle to the horizon is studied. Air resistance force and Magnus force are taken into account with the use of the quadratic laws. We consider the asymptotic motion of the projectile, i.e., the motion on a sufficiently large time interval. The equations of motion are written both in Cartesian coordinates and in natural axes. The aim of the study is the analytical determination of the characteristics of asymptotic motion - the limiting angle of inclination of the trajectory to the horizontal and the terminal velocity, and obtaining an analytical representation for the velocity hodograph. No restrictions are imposed on the initial throwing conditions and other parameters. The equations of motion in Cartesian coordinates are used to find the angle of inclination of the trajectory and the terminal velocity. The equations of motion in natural axes are used to determine velocity hodograph. The velocity hodograph is defined in the form an approximate implicit analytical formula linking the trajectory angle of the projectile to its velocity. The motion of a golf ball, is presented as example. Numerical calculations show a complete coincidence of analytically found values of required quantities with numerically found values. The proposed analytical formulas can be useful for all researchers of this classical problem
Classical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the asymptotic motion characteristics of moving objects (such as golf balls) when considering air resistance and Magnus force. Specifically, the author focuses on the following two aspects: 1. **Determination of asymptotic motion characteristics**: - **Limit inclination angle**: That is, the inclination angle \(\theta_{\text{term}}\) of the trajectory finally relative to the horizontal plane. - **Terminal velocity**: That is, the final velocity \(V_{\text{term}}\) at which the object tends to be stable after a long - time motion. 2. **Obtaining the analytical expression of the velocity hodograph**: - The velocity hodograph is a graph that describes the trajectory of the end point of the velocity vector. The author aims to derive an approximate implicit analytical formula that relates the velocity to the trajectory angle. ### Derivation process of the formula #### Determination of asymptotic motion characteristics To determine the characteristics of asymptotic motion, the author uses the following steps: 1. **Establishment of motion equations**: - Write the motion equations in the Cartesian coordinate system and the natural coordinate system respectively. The motion equations in the Cartesian coordinate system are: \[ \frac{dV_x}{dt}=-g k_1 V\sin\theta - g k_2 V\cos\theta \] \[ \frac{dV_y}{dt}=-g + g k_1 V\cos\theta\pm g k_2 V\sin\theta \] - The motion equations in the natural coordinate system are: \[ m\frac{d^2 s}{dt^2}=-mg\sin\theta - mg k_1 V^2 - mg k_2 V^2\cos\theta \] \[ m V\frac{d\theta}{dt}=-mg\cos\theta + mg k_2 V^2\sin\theta \] 2. **Solution of the limit inclination angle**: - Assume that in the asymptotic state, both the velocity \(V\) and the angle \(\theta\) tend to be stable, we can get: \[ \sin\theta + k_2\cos\theta = 0 \] - The limit inclination angle is solved as: \[ \theta_{\text{term}}=\arctan\left(-\frac{1}{k_2}\right) \] 3. **Solution of the terminal velocity**: - Using the second motion equation, in the asymptotic state, \(V_y\) also tends to be stable, we can get: \[ V_{\text{term}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{k_1^2 + k_2^2}} \] #### Analytical expression of the velocity hodograph To obtain the analytical expression of the velocity hodograph, the author transforms and integrates the motion equations in the natural coordinate system, and finally obtains an implicit function: \[ f(V,\theta) = 0 \] The specific form is: \[ \ln(\cos\theta)+\frac{1}{2}\ln\left(\tan^2\frac{\theta}{2}\right)+\frac{0.24}{\cos^3\theta}+\frac{3}{\cos\theta}=C \] where \(C\) is a constant. ### Conclusion Through the above analysis, the author successfully derives the limit inclination angle and terminal velocity of the asymptotic motion, and gives an approximate analytical expression of the velocity hodograph. These formulas have