Conformity assessment of processes and lots in the framework of JCGM 106:2012

Rainer Göb,Steffen Uhlig,Bernard Colson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2409.11912
2024-09-18
Abstract:ISO/IEC 17000:2020 defines conformity assessment as an "activity to determine whether specified requirements relating to a product, process, system, person or body are fulfilled". JCGM (2012) establishes a framework for accounting for measurement uncertainty in conformity assessment. The focus of JCGM (2012) is on the conformity assessment of individual units of product based on measurements on a cardinal continuous scale. However, the scheme can also be applied to composite assessment targets like finite lots of product or manufacturing processes, and to the evaluation of characteristics in discrete cardinal or nominal scales. We consider the application of the JCGM scheme in the conformity assessment of finite lots or processes of discrete units subject to a dichotomous quality classification as conforming and nonconforming. A lot or process is classified as conforming if the actual proportion nonconforming does not exceed a prescribed upper tolerance limit, otherwise the lot or process is classified as nonconforming. The measurement on the lot or process is a statistical estimation of the proportion nonconforming based on attributes or variables sampling, and meassurement uncertainty is sampling uncertainty. Following JCGM (2012), we analyse the effect of measurement uncertainty (sampling uncertainty) in attributes sampling, and we calculate key conformity assessment parameters, in particular the producer's and consumer's risk. We suggest to integrate such parameters as a useful add-on into ISO acceptance sampling standards such as the ISO 2859 series.
Applications
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to conduct conformity assessment for finite batches or processes under the framework of JCGM 106:2012. Specifically, the purpose of the research is to apply the measurement uncertainty handling method in JCGM 106:2012 to the conformity assessment of finite batches of discrete units or continuous processes, especially in the case of binary quality classification (conforming and non - conforming). ### Main problems and background 1. **ISO/IEC 17000:2020 definition**: Conformity assessment refers to "the activity of determining whether specific requirements are met", and these requirements can involve products, processes, systems, individuals or institutions. 2. **JCGM 106:2012 framework**: This framework establishes a method for considering measurement uncertainty in conformity assessment. JCGM 106:2012 mainly focuses on the conformity assessment of single product units based on continuous - scale measurement. However, this framework can also be applied to composite assessment targets, such as finite batches or manufacturing processes, and can be used to assess characteristics on discrete or nominal scales. 3. **Existing problems**: The current ISO acceptance sampling standards (such as the ISO 2859 series) are mainly used for attribute sampling and variable sampling, but they do not fully consider the impact of measurement uncertainty on conformity assessment. In addition, the principles of traditional acceptance sampling (H1 and H2) are in contradiction with the concepts of modern quality control systems, which emphasize the coordinated exchange of information and the integration of various control functions. ### Research objectives - **Adapt to the JCGM 106:2012 framework**: Apply the framework of JCGM 106:2012 to the conformity assessment of finite batches or continuous processes, especially when the units in these processes or batches are classified as conforming or non - conforming. - **Calculate key indicators**: Analyze the impact of measurement uncertainty (i.e., sampling uncertainty) on attribute sampling, and calculate key conformity assessment parameters, especially the producer risk and the consumer risk. - **Supplement ISO standards**: It is recommended to include these parameters as useful supplements in ISO acceptance sampling standards (such as the ISO 2859 series), so that these standards can better reflect the requirements of modern quality control, for example, by handling prior knowledge about batch or process quality and providing information about conformity. ### Specific applications - **Statistical estimation**: Through sampling of finite batches or processes, statistically estimate the non - conforming proportion and compare it with the specified upper tolerance limit. - **Bayesian analysis**: Use the Bayesian analysis method to handle the relationship between prior information and measurement results, calculate the posterior conditional probability distribution, and assess conformity according to these probabilities. - **Risk assessment**: Calculate specific consumer risks and producer risks, as well as global risks, to ensure the reliability of the assessment process. Through these methods, this research aims to improve the accuracy and reliability of conformity assessment, especially in the modern industrial environment, to ensure the effectiveness of product quality control.