DeFi Arbitrage in Hedged Liquidity Tokens

Maxim Bichuch,Zachary Feinstein

2024-09-18

Abstract:Empirically, the prevailing market prices for liquidity tokens of the constant product market maker (CPMM) -- as offered in practice by companies such as Uniswap -- readily permit arbitrage opportunities by delta hedging the risk of the position. Herein, we investigate this arbitrage opportunity by treating the liquidity token as a derivative position in the prices of the underlying assets for the CPMM. In doing so, not dissimilar to the Black-Scholes result, we deduce risk-neutral pricing and hedging formulas for these liquidity tokens. Furthermore, with our novel pricing formula, we construct a method to calibrate a volatility to data which provides an updated (non-market) price which would not permit arbitrage if quoted by the CPMM. We conclude with a discussion of novel AMM designs which would bring the pricing of liquidity tokens into the modern financial era.

Mathematical Finance,Pricing of Securities,Risk Management

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to solve the problems of pricing and hedging of liquidity tokens in decentralized finance (DeFi). Specifically, the author focuses on the automated market makers (AMMs) of the constant product market maker (CPMM) type, such as the liquidity tokens provided by Uniswap. These tokens are prone to arbitrage opportunities under current market conditions.

#### Main problems

1. **Arbitrage opportunities**: The existing CPMM liquidity token pricing mechanism has obvious arbitrage opportunities. Through empirical analysis, the author finds that the prices of liquidity tokens on platforms such as Uniswap do not always reflect their true values, enabling investors to profit through the Delta hedging strategy.

2. **Lack of pricing and hedging theories**: Currently, there is a lack of risk - neutral pricing and hedging theories for CPMM liquidity tokens. This makes it difficult for liquidity providers (LPs) to effectively manage their investment risks, and may lead to large - scale LPs' losses (for example, nearly 50% of LPs lose money on Uniswap as mentioned in the paper).

3. **Insufficient application of modern financial tools**: The design of existing AMMs fails to fully utilize modern financial tools and theories, such as the risk - neutral pricing method in the Black - Scholes model. Therefore, new AMM designs need to be introduced to make the pricing of liquidity tokens more in line with the requirements of the modern financial market.

#### Solutions

1. **Risk - neutral pricing formula**: The author proposes a new risk - neutral pricing formula for calculating the value of CPMM liquidity tokens. This formula takes into account factors such as asset price fluctuations and trading fees, and derives the corresponding hedging strategies (Greeks).

2. **Calibrating arbitrage - free prices**: Based on the newly proposed pricing formula, the author develops a method to calibrate the implied volatility, thereby providing an updated, arbitrage - free price for liquidity tokens. This price can better reflect the actual market situation and avoid the generation of arbitrage opportunities.

3. **New AMM design**: In order to further eliminate arbitrage opportunities and improve the pricing efficiency of liquidity tokens, the author discusses several novel AMM design schemes. For example, introducing variable minting / burning costs or adjusting the trading fee rate to ensure that the price of liquidity tokens can be dynamically adjusted according to market conditions.

#### Formula summary

- **Risk - neutral pricing formula**:
\[
V_0(P)=\max\left\{2\sqrt{P}, e^{-r\Delta t}\mathbb{E}\left[V_0\left(Pe^{(r - \frac{\sigma^2}{2})\Delta t+\sigma B_{\Delta t}}\right)+\hat{\gamma}F\left(P, Pe^{(r - \frac{\sigma^2}{2})\Delta t+\sigma B_{\Delta t}}\right)\right]\right\}
\]

- **Optimal investment condition**:
\[
\hat{\gamma}\geq\hat{\gamma}^* := 2\left[-1+\frac{\Phi\left(\frac{(r+\frac{\sigma^2}{2})\sqrt{\Delta t}}{\sigma}\right)-e^{-r\Delta t}\Phi\left(\frac{(r-\frac{\sigma^2}{2})\sqrt{\Delta t}}{\sigma}\right)}{1 - e^{-\frac{1}{2}(r+\frac{\sigma^2}{4})\Delta t}}\right]^{-1}
\]

- **Value of liquidity tokens**:
\[
V_0(P_0)=\frac{2\hat{\gamma}\sqrt{P_0}}{\hat{\gamma}^*}