Abstract:How to design a fair and reasonable allocation plan for the common revenue of the alliance is considered in this paper. We regard the common revenue to be allocated as an exogenous variable which will not participate in the subsequent production process. The production organizations can cooperate with each other and form alliances. As the DEA cross-efficiency combines self- and peer-evaluation mechanisms, and the cooperative game allows fair negotiation among participants, we combine the cross-efficiency with the cooperative game theory and construct the modified Shapley value to reflect the contribution of the evaluated participant to the alliance. In addition, for each participant, both the optimistic and the pessimistic modified Shapley values are considered, and thus the upper and lower bounds of the allocation revenue are obtained, correspondingly. A numerical example is presented to illustrate the operation procedure. Finally, we apply the approach to an empirical application concerning a city commercial bank with 18 branches in China.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to design a fair and reasonable common income distribution plan, especially for production organizations in the alliance. Specifically, the author focuses on how to fairly distribute common income or fixed costs among alliance members, so that the distribution result of each participant (i.e., decision - making unit, DMU) reflects both overall fairness and satisfies the satisfaction of individual participants.
### Specific description of the main problem:
1. **Common income as an exogenous variable**: The paper regards common income as an exogenous variable, that is, it will not participate in the subsequent production process. This means that the income allocated to a certain DMU will not directly affect its production efficiency or other output indicators.
2. **Cooperative and competitive relationships**: Participants in the alliance have both cooperative and competitive relationships. Therefore, the distribution plan needs to consider these two relationships simultaneously to ensure fairness and rationality.
3. **Limitations of existing methods**: In most of the existing literature on resource allocation problems, the allocated resources are usually regarded as additional inputs and are distributed following the principles of efficiency invariance or efficiency maximization. However, the reality is that the allocated resources (such as bonuses, profits, etc.) should usually not be regarded as part of the input or output, but should be regarded as exogenous variables. Therefore, traditional distribution methods may not be fully applicable to this situation.
### Solution:
To solve the above problems, the author proposes an improved Shapley value method based on DEA (Data Envelopment Analysis) cross - efficiency and cooperative game theory. The specific steps are as follows:
1. **Combining cross - efficiency and cooperative games**: By combining DEA cross - efficiency and cooperative game theory, an improved Shapley value is constructed to reflect the contribution of each DMU to the alliance.
2. **Calculating optimistic and pessimistic improved Shapley values**: For each participant, calculate its optimistic and pessimistic improved Shapley values respectively, so as to obtain the upper and lower bounds of the distribution income.
3. **Application examples**: The effectiveness and feasibility of this method are verified through numerical examples and practical applications (such as the income distribution of 18 branches of a city commercial bank in China).
### Formula summary:
- **Cross - efficiency formula**:
\[
E_{ij}=\frac{\sum_{r = 1}^{s}u_{r}^{*}y_{rj}}{\sum_{i = 1}^{m}v_{i}^{*}x_{ij}}, \quad j=1,2,\ldots,n
\]
where \(E_{ij}\) represents the cross - efficiency of DMU \(j\) to DMU \(i\), and \(u_{r}^{*}\) and \(v_{i}^{*}\) are the optimal weights of the \(r\) - th output and the \(i\) - th input respectively.
- **Improved Shapley value formula**:
\[
\phi_{i}(v)=\sum_{S\subseteq N\setminus\{i\}}\frac{|S|!(n - |S|- 1)!}{n!}\left(\frac{v(S\cup\{i\})-v(S)}{\sum_{j\in S\cup\{i\}}E_{j}-\sum_{j\in S}E_{j}}\right)
\]
where \(\phi_{i}(v)\) represents the improved Shapley value of DMU \(i\), \(v(S)\) is the characteristic function value of the alliance \(S\), and \(E_{j}\) is the cross - efficiency of DMU \(j\).
### Conclusion:
The method proposed in this paper can not only distribute common income fairly and reasonably, but also provide flexibility for practical applications by calculating the upper and lower bounds, ensuring that the distribution plan can maintain rationality in different situations.