Un índice discreto sensible a la desigualdad

Francisco José Zamudio Sánchez,Javier Jiménez Machorro,Roxana Arana Ovalle,Hildegardo Martínez Silverio

2024-09-12

Abstract:This paper introduces the Relative Inequality Index at the Maximum (IDRM), a novel and intuitive measure designed to capture inequality within a population, such as income inequality. The index is based on the idea that individuals experience varying levels of inequality depending on their position within the distribution, particularly with respect to those at the top. The key assumption is that for individuals in lower positions, inequalities referenced to the top positions have greater impact on their well-being and the inequality relative to maximum is the most critical. The IDRM fulfills desirable theoretical properties which were used for its evaluation and comparison against widely accepted measures in inequality literature. From this perspective, the IDRM is shown to be as robust as traditional measures and outperforms the Gini and Dalton indices by satisfying eight out of nine key properties, including decomposability across population subgroups. In a comparative analysis using income data from 58 countries and microdata from Mexico, with the Gini, Theil, and Atkinson indices as benchmarks, the IDRM demonstrates superior consistency, sensitivity to inequality, reduced bias in grouped data, and enhanced precision. This index reflects the varying forms of income distribution, showing heightened sensitivity to the magnitude of inequality.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

The paper aims to propose a new inequality measurement index - the Index of Relative Inequality with Respect to the Maximum (IDRM) to more accurately capture the inequality within groups, especially income inequality. The core problem of the paper is that some of the existing commonly - used inequality indices (such as the Gini coefficient, Theil index and Atkinson index) are not sensitive enough when reflecting certain types of inequality changes, especially the changes between the high - end and low - end of the income distribution.

### Main contributions

1. **Proposing a new index**:
- **Definition of IDRM**: IDRM is constructed based on the degree of inequality of each individual relative to the highest - income earner in the group. Specifically, for each individual \( i \), its inequality value \( d_i \) is defined as:
\[
d_i=\frac{x_{\text{max}}-x_i}{x_{\text{max}}}
\]
where \( x_{\text{max}} \) is the highest income in the group and \( x_i \) is the income of individual \( i \).

2. **Theoretical properties**:
- **Properties satisfied**: IDRM satisfies eight out of the nine properties that an ideal inequality measurement index should have, including anonymity, scale invariance, replication invariance, transfer principle, sensitivity principle, non - negativity, zero - equality, maximum - inequality and sub - group decomposability.
- **Property not satisfied**: IDRM does not satisfy the strong - sensitivity principle, but performs well under the weak - sensitivity principle.

3. **Empirical analysis**:
- **Data sources**: The paper uses income data from 58 countries and micro - data from Mexico for analysis.
- **Comparison benchmarks**: It is compared with the Gini coefficient, Theil index and Atkinson index.
- **Results**: IDRM performs well in terms of consistency, sensitivity to inequality, reducing grouped - data bias and improving precision, especially in reflecting different forms of income distribution and high inequality.

### Conclusion

By introducing IDRM, the paper provides a new and more sensitive method of measuring inequality, especially in reflecting the differences between high - end and low - end incomes. This index not only satisfies most of the ideal properties theoretically, but also shows superior performance in practical applications. This makes IDRM a valuable tool for evaluating and understanding socio - economic inequality.