Comment on Room-temperature spontaneous superradiance from single diamond nanocrystals [Nat. Commun. 8, 1205 (2017)]

Jakub J. Borkowski,Artur Czerwinski,Piotr Kolenderski

2024-08-27

Abstract:The paper by C. Bradac et al. [Nat. Commun. 8, 1205 (2017)] discusses room-temperature superradiance from NV color centers in diamonds. It presents a new model intended to reflect experimental characteristics of this phenomenon. To validate the model, the authors provide experimental results that are subsequently compared with numerical calculations derived from the scheme. Motivated by our own experiments with the fluorescence of similar NV samples, we attempted to create a theoretical model to accurately describe experimental systems. Initially, we aimed to incorporate the numerical equations from Bradac et al.'s paper's supplement into our own theoretical framework. However, we encountered numerous issues resulting in non-physical results such as negative photon counts or non-zero asymptotic fluorescence intensity. We identified these inconsistencies and proposed amendments to rectify them. We have developed our own framework by correctly reinterpreting the terms of the master equation. The resulting formulas produce physically meaningful results consistent with experimental data.

Quantum Physics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Computational Physics,Optics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the inaccuracy of the theoretical model regarding the phenomenon of spontaneous superradiance in nitrogen-vacancy (NV) color centers in diamond nanocrystals at room temperature. Specifically, the authors point out several physically unreasonable results in the theoretical model proposed by C. Bradac et al. in their paper published in *Nature Communications* (Nat. Commun. 8, 1205 (2017)), such as negative photon counts and non-zero asymptotic fluorescence intensity. These issues lead to inconsistencies between the model and experimental data.

To verify and improve this model, the authors conducted the following work:
1. **Model Evaluation**: Through numerical simulations, the authors found that the original model (Model A) produced fluorescence patterns that significantly differed from experimental results when dealing with a small number of color centers (e.g., 7 color centers).
2. **Physical Unreasonableness**: The authors identified several physically unreasonable behaviors in the original model, such as fluorescence intensity dropping to negative values at certain times and non-zero asymptotic fluorescence intensity.
3. **Model Revision**: The authors proposed a new theoretical model (Model B), which corrected these unreasonableness by reinterpreting the terms in the master equation, making the model results more consistent with physical principles and experimental data.

In summary, the main goal of this paper is to propose a more accurate theoretical model to describe the phenomenon of spontaneous superradiance in NV color centers in diamond nanocrystals at room temperature, addressing the physical unreasonableness and inconsistencies with experimental data present in the existing model.