Surface roughness effects in a transonic axial flow compressor operating at near-stall conditions

Prashant B. Godse,Harshal D. Akolekar,A. M. Pradeep

2024-09-11

Abstract:Surface roughness is a major contributor to performance degradation in gas turbine engines. The fan and the compressor, as the first components in the engine's air path, are especially vulnerable to the effects of surface roughness. Debris ingestion, accumulation of grime, dust, or insect remnants, typically at low atmospheric conditions, over several cycles of operation are some major causes of surface roughness over the blade surfaces. The flow in compressor rotors is inherently highly complex. From the perspective of the component designers, it is thus important to study the effect of surface roughness on the performance and flow physics, especially at near-stall conditions. In this study, we examine the effect of surface roughness on flow physics such as shock-boundary layer interactions, tip and hub flow separations, the formation and changes in the critical points, and tip leakage vortices amongst other phenomena. Steady and unsteady Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) calculations are conducted at near-stall conditions for smooth and rough NASA (National Aeronautics and Space Administration) rotor 67 blades. Surface streamlines, Q-criterion, and entropy contours aid in analyzing the flow physics qualitatively and quantitatively. It is observed that from the onset of stall, to fully stalled conditions, the blockage varies from 21.7\% to 59.6\% from 90\% span to the tip in the smooth case, and from 40.5\% to 75.2\% in the rough case. This significant blockage, caused by vortex breakdown and chaotic flow structures, leads to the onset of full rotor stall.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to investigate the impact of surface roughness on the performance and flow physics of a transonic axial flow compressor under near-stall conditions. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Impact of Surface Roughness on Flow Physics**:
- Shock-boundary layer interactions
- Tip and hub flow separations
- Formation and changes in the critical points
- Tip leakage vortices and other phenomena

2. **Numerical Simulation Methods**:
- Using steady and unsteady Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) equations to study the flow characteristics of NASA Rotor 67 blades with smooth and rough surfaces under near-stall conditions.

3. **Experimental Validation**:
- Validating the accuracy of numerical simulations by comparing them with experimental data to ensure the reliability of the results.

4. **Performance Loss Analysis**:
- Quantifying the flow blockage caused by surface roughness and its impact on compressor performance, especially under near-stall conditions.

### Research Background

- **Impact of Surface Roughness**: Surface roughness is one of the main factors leading to the performance degradation of gas turbine engines. Especially, the fan and compressor, as the first components in the engine intake path, are more susceptible to the effects of surface roughness.
- **Flow Complexity**: The flow in a compressor rotor is very complex, involving multiple flow mechanisms such as tip leakage vortices, shock waves, mixed flows, and shock-boundary layer interactions.
- **Research Significance**: Understanding the impact of surface roughness on flow physics helps designers optimize compressor design, improve its stability and efficiency, and reduce wear during long-term operation.

### Main Research Content

- **Numerical Simulation**: Using RANS methods for steady and unsteady calculations to study the flow characteristics of NASA Rotor 67 blades with smooth and rough surfaces under near-stall conditions.
- **Flow Analysis**: Qualitatively and quantitatively analyzing flow physics through surface streamlines, Q-criterion, and entropy contours.
- **Performance Evaluation**: Evaluating the changes in flow blockage and its impact on compressor performance from the onset of stall to complete stall.

### Key Findings

- **Smooth Blades**: From the onset of stall to complete stall, the blockage rate from 90% span to the tip increased from 21.7% to 59.6%.
- **Rough Blades**: Under the same conditions, the blockage rate from 90% span to the tip increased from 40.5% to 75.2%.
- **Flow Blockage**: Significant blockage caused by vortex breakdown and chaotic flow structures leads to complete rotor stall.

Through these studies, the authors hope to provide a scientific basis for understanding and mitigating the impact of surface roughness on compressor performance, thereby optimizing design and maintenance strategies.