A Novel Idea Generation Tool using a Structured Conversational AI (CAI) System

B. Sankar,Dibakar Sen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2409.05747

2024-09-10

Abstract:This paper presents a novel conversational AI-enabled active ideation interface as a creative idea-generation tool to assist novice designers in mitigating the initial latency and ideation bottlenecks that are commonly observed. It is a dynamic, interactive, and contextually responsive approach, actively involving a large language model (LLM) from the domain of natural language processing (NLP) in artificial intelligence (AI) to produce multiple statements of potential ideas for different design problems. Integrating such AI models with ideation creates what we refer to as an Active Ideation scenario, which helps foster continuous dialogue-based interaction, context-sensitive conversation, and prolific idea generation. A pilot study was conducted with thirty novice designers to generate ideas for given problems using traditional methods and the new CAI-based interface. The key parameters of fluency, novelty, and variety were used to compare the outcomes qualitatively by a panel of experts. The findings demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed tool for generating prolific, diverse and novel ideas. The interface was enhanced by incorporating a prompt-engineered structured dialogue style for each ideation stage to make it uniform and more convenient for the designers. The resulting responses of such a structured CAI interface were found to be more succinct and aligned towards the subsequent design stage, namely conceptualization. The paper thus established the rich potential of using Generative AI (Gen-AI) for the early ill-structured phase of the creative product design process.

Human-Computer Interaction,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the ideation bottlenecks faced by novice designers in the early stages of product design. Specifically, these problems include:

1. **Lack of Experience**: Due to a lack of experience in handling diverse design challenges or an insufficient knowledge base, novice designers may find it difficult to generate valuable design ideas. This may lead to a small number of ideas that lack depth and practicality, affecting the quality and novelty of design solutions.

2. **Design Fixation**: Designers may rely too much on the first few ideas and be unwilling or unable to deviate from these initial concepts. This fixation not only limits the scope of exploration but also hinders the consideration of other potentially better ideas, thus limiting the innovation potential of the design.

3. **Cognitive Fatigue**: The continuous ideation process can lead to the depletion of cognitive resources, manifested as a decline in the ability to generate diverse ideas. This will prevent designers from establishing connections between different ideas, resulting in homogenized ideas and an inability to push the boundaries of the design solution space.

4. **Mental Block**: Designers may find themselves unable to generate new ideas, manifested as a blank mind or repeatedly returning to previously discarded ideas. This situation may be caused by stress, the pressure to innovate, or over - immersion in the current problem, leading to a stagnation of the creative process.

To solve the above problems, the paper proposes a new ideation - generation tool based on a structured Conversational AI (CAI) system. This tool aims to help novice designers overcome ideation bottlenecks and inspire more innovative ideas through dynamic interaction with large - language models (LLM). By comparing the effects of traditional methods and the newly proposed CAI system, the paper verifies the effectiveness of this tool in increasing the quantity, diversity, and novelty of ideation - generation.