Abstract:The year 2024 witnessed a major development in the cryptocurrency industry with the long-awaited approval of spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs). This innovation provides investors with a new, regulated path to gain exposure to Bitcoin through a familiar investment vehicle (Kumar et al., 2024). However, unlike traditional ETFs that directly hold underlying assets, Bitcoin ETFs rely on a creation and redemption process managed by authorized participants (APs). This unique structure introduces distinct characteristics in terms of premium/discount behavior compared to traditional ETFs. This paper investigates the premium and discount patterns observed in Bitcoin ETFs during first four-month period (January 11th, 2024, to May 17th, 2024). Our analysis reveals that these patterns differ significantly from those observed in traditional index ETFs, potentially exposing investors to additional risk factors. By identifying and analyzing these risk factors associated with Bitcoin ETF premiums/discounts, this paper aims to achieve two key objectives: Enhance market understanding: Equip and market and investors with a deeper comprehension of the unique liquidity risks inherent in Bitcoin ETFs. Provide a clearer risk management frameworks: Offer a clearer perspective on the risk-return profile of digital asset ETFs, specifically focusing on Bitcoin ETFs. Through a thorough analysis of premium/discount behavior and the underlying factors contributing to it, this paper strives to contribute valuable insights for investors navigating the evolving landscape of digital asset investments
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore the premium and discount patterns of Bitcoin exchange - traded funds (Bitcoin ETFs) during the first four months of 2024 (from January 11th to May 17th). The study found that these patterns are significantly different from those of traditional index ETFs and may expose investors to additional risk factors. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following aspects:
1. **Enhancing market understanding**: By analyzing the premium and discount behaviors of Bitcoin ETFs, help the market and investors gain a deeper understanding of the unique liquidity risks inherent in these financial instruments.
2. **Providing a clearer risk - management framework**: Provide a clearer risk - return profile for digital - asset ETFs, especially Bitcoin ETFs, to help investors better manage and assess investment risks.
### Research methods
The paper adopted a quantitative analysis method and compared the premium and discount data of five major Bitcoin ETFs. In the study, the premium or discount ratio between the ETF price and its net asset value (NAV) is defined as:
\[ P_t=\frac{P_t - NAV_t}{NAV_t}\times100\% \]
where \( P_t \) represents the price per share of the ETF, and \( NAV_t \) represents the net asset value per share.
To explore the factors affecting the premium and discount ratios, the paper used a linear regression model:
\[ \text{Premium Discount}=\alpha+\beta_1\text{Volume}+\beta_2\text{Daily Return}+\beta_3\text{NAV}+\epsilon \]
where trading volume (Volume), daily return rate (Daily Return), and net asset value (NAV) are independent variables, and the premium or discount ratio is the dependent variable.
### Main findings
1. **Relationship between size and volatility**: The study found that smaller Bitcoin ETFs (judged by their net asset values) exhibit greater premium and discount fluctuations, indicating that investors may face higher liquidity risks in smaller Bitcoin ETFs.
2. **Relationship between trading volume and premium/discount**: Preliminary observations show that an increase in trading volume may be associated with a wider premium/discount ratio, but further research is needed to confirm this association and the underlying mechanisms.
3. **Tracking error**: Compared with traditional index ETFs, Bitcoin ETFs have a larger tracking error between their market prices and net asset values, indicating that Bitcoin ETFs may not well reflect the price changes of their underlying assets, increasing investment risks.
### Risk factors
1. **Market risk**: Bitcoin's high price volatility and potential security risks (such as hacking, technical vulnerabilities) may lead to losses for investors.
2. **Liquidity risk**: The liquidity of Bitcoin ETFs is affected by market depth, the trading volume of the ETF itself, market trading hours, and the creation and redemption mechanisms.
### Risk - management strategies
1. **Diversification**: Reduce the volatility and risks brought by Bitcoin ETFs through portfolio diversification.
2. **Liquidity assessment**: Regularly assess the liquidity of Bitcoin ETFs and their underlying assets, and select ETFs with higher trading volumes and more efficient creation/redemption mechanisms.
3. **Monitoring regulatory developments**: Timely understand regulatory changes and their impacts on the cryptocurrency market.
4. **Using derivatives**: Use options and futures contracts to hedge potential price changes and manage market risks.
Through these analyses and suggestions, the paper aims to provide investors with a more comprehensive understanding and risk - management tools to help them make more informed decisions in the ever - evolving digital - asset investment field.