Abstract:The Best Worst Method (BWM), a reduced version of the AHP, is a recent multi-criteria decision-making tool based on pairwise comparisons with reference to the best and worst criteria. Consistency Ratio (CR) measurement for the rating quality and prioritizations is still a controversial topic. Firstly, the computation for the current CR of BWM must rely on a software optimization solver to find the optimal values, and the solver may not always guarantee the exact optimal solutions, especially if the computational cost settings are not large enough for higher number of criteria. Secondly, much effort to evaluate optimization algorithms is needed to find the best solutions with the least computational resources due to diverse solvers possibly leading to different results with different performances. Thirdly, optimization programming code is not trivial to be implemented for general BWM users. To address these issues, this paper presents the closed-form solutions, Max of Edge Error Matrix (MEEM) (Eq. (44) of Theorem 4) and Minmax Edge Error Determinant (MEED) (Algorithm 1), to replace the BWM optimization models to directly calculate the CR values. Two simulations have been performed with a basic laptop using a single process. One simulation of twenty thousand random pairs of vectors took 26.34 h to perform to verify that the approximate results are higher than or very close to the exact closed-form values of both methods when high computational cost is allocated for the solver to increase the precision. Another simulation of one million random pairs of vectors only took 1.27 h to perform to verify that the MEED and MEEM methods always produce the same results for the number of criteria up to nine. The computational time for the exact results is dramatically reduced when the solver is not needed. The advantages of the proposed solutions include the following: the software to solve the optimization model to obtain CR is unnecessary, and the proposed calculation is extremely efficient to obtain the exact accuracy. The two-step optimization model can preserve the fixed Minmax Edge Error to find the weights which add up to one, which is the condition to determine if the model reaches exact optimal solutions. As the CR optimization model produces multiple versions of weights, which are recommended not to be used, the new method does not need to compute the unnecessary weight values to get the Minmax Edge Error. With the provision of equations leading to closed forms, users can understand the properties of CR in much clearer perspectives. Due to the computational efficiency and explainability, the proposed closed forms can replace the CR optimization model to compute CR efficiently and accurately for all diverse applications using BWM.

Taxicab distance based best-worst method for multi-criteria decision-making: An analytical approach

An analytic framework for the multiplicative best-worst method

An α-cut intervals based fuzzy best-Worst method for Multi-Criteria Decision-Making

A New Approach for Bicriteria Partitioning Problem

Hierarchical Decision-making using a New Mathematical Model based on the Best-worst Method

An Interval-Valued Best–Worst Method with Normal Distribution for Multi-criteria Decision-Making

Best-Worst Disaggregation: An approach to the preference disaggregation problem

A Hybrid Best-Worst Method (BWM)—Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) Approach for Prioritizing Road Safety Improvements

Closed-form Solutions of Consistency Ratio in Best Worst Method Minmax Optimization Model: Max of Edge Error Matrix and Minmax Edge Error Determinant Methods

Integrated MADM approach based on extended MABAC method with Aczel–Alsina generalized weighted Bonferroni mean operator

A Modified CRITIC Method to Estimate the Objective Weights of Decision Criteria

Cloud Model-Based Best-Worst Method for Group Decision Making under Uncertainty

BHARAT: A simple and effective multi-criteria decision-making method that does not need fuzzy logic, Part-2: Role in multi- and many-objective optimization problems

A weighting model based on best–worst method and its application for environmental performance evaluation

A Rough–fuzzy Approach Integrating Best–worst Method and Data Envelopment Analysis to Multi-Criteria Selection of Smart Product Service Module

A Study of Decision Process in MCDM Problems with Large Number of Criteria

A hybrid Bayesian BWM and Pythagorean fuzzy WASPAS-based decision-making framework for parcel locker location selection problem

A hybrid multi-criteria decision-making framework of EWM-BWM-TODIM based on Linguistic Pythagorean fuzzy environment

A normal wiggly hesitant fuzzy MABAC method based on CCSD and prospect theory for multiple attribute decision making

A model for determining weights of criteria using subjective and objective information

An Extended Taxonomy Method Based on Normal T-Spherical Fuzzy Numbers for Multiple-Attribute Decision-Making