Priority Pricing for Clean Power Under Uncertainty
Hung-po Chao,Shmuel Oren,Robert Wilson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40518-022-00202-1
2022-07-28
Current Sustainable/Renewable Energy Reports
Abstract:AbstractPurpose of ReviewClimate change has become a defining issue on a global scale. With declining costs, renewables have expanded rapidly to become the preferred clean energy resources for electricity generation. With salient features of zero marginal cost and supply uncertainty, renewables present unique challenges to the electricity market design and price formation for long-run efficiency. The purpose of this paper is to review the impact of metering technology on demand-side management and price formation. We compared three cases, integrated resource planning, ex ante linear pricing, and priority service pricing, with different levels of metering technology. The cases are clarified with numerical examples, and the results are compared in terms of capacity level, capacity cost, service reliability, and social welfare.Recent FindingsTraditionally, the electric utility industry has relied on integrated resource planning and central system operations to meet the growing demand and maintain a standard level of service reliability. During the past two decades, the liberalization of electricity markets has transformed the traditional industry practice with the introduction of market-based locational marginal pricing for improved economic efficiency. As evidenced by recent research, a growing consensus has emerged that the future transition to renewables with zero marginal cost and supply uncertainty would present fundamental challenges to the current market designs.SummaryIn this paper, we examine demand-side management with priority service addressing price formation and financial viability of merchant investments from a risk perspective to guide practical pricing and investment policy decisions in the presence of supply uncertainty. To illuminate the issue, we study a few highly simplified cases for a clean power economy in the environment of a large remote island running solely on renewable energy sources, e.g., solar and winds. To meet the local electricity needs, we address several key issues including: How would the system operator keep the lights on when demand fluctuates continuously over days, weeks, and seasons, but supply is unpredictable and difficult to control? How should the price of electricity be set when the short-run marginal cost is zero? How would the market attract investments to meet the growing demand in the long term? What would be the impacts on the service reliability? To address practical implementation issues, we discuss a stochastic auction-based market platform that enables innovative demand-side management harnessing flexibility via an end-to-end business model, in ways that flexible demand devices (e.g., hot water heaters, air conditioners, energy storage) on the customer end are aggregated into a “virtual power plant” submitted by an aggregator through a supply function offer into the wholesale market as demand reserve.