Abstract:We study the Factorization Paradox from the bottom up by adapting methods from perturbative renormalization. Just as quantum field theories are plagued with loop divergences that need to be cancelled systematically by introducing counterterms, gravitational path integrals are plagued by wormhole contributions that spoil the factorization of the holographic dual. These wormholes must be cancelled by some stringy effects in a UV complete, holographic theory of quantum gravity. In a simple model of two-dimensional topological gravity, we outline a gravitational analog of the recursive BPHZ procedure in order to systematically introduce ``counter-wormholes" which parametrize the unknown stringy effects that lead to factorization. Underlying this procedure is a Hopf algebra of symmetries which is analogous to the Connes--Kreimer Hopf algebra underlying perturbative renormalization. The group dual to this Hopf algebra acts to reorganize contributions from spacetimes with distinct topology, and can be seen as a gauge group relating various equivalent ways of constructing a factorizing gravitational path integral.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the Factorization Paradox caused by topological changes in the quantum - gravity path integral. Specifically, the paper explores how to systematically eliminate the non - factorizable effects in the path integral caused by wormhole contributions by introducing "counter - wormholes", thereby restoring the consistency of the holographic duality theory. This problem stems from the direct conflict between the holographic principle and the gravitational path integral that includes topological changes. The holographic principle requires that quantum gravity defines a local quantum field theory (QFT) living on the spacetime boundary, while the spatial configuration of the gravitational path integral is given by the set of bulk spacetime manifolds with fixed boundaries, which is not limited to the boundary. In particular, although the holographic principle requires that the correlation functions with disconnected boundaries must be factorized, there are non - factorizable configurations in the gravitational path integral, namely the so - called spacetime wormholes.
To solve this paradox, the paper proposes a compact formal analogy, that is, to analogize these additional non - localities (i.e., counter - wormholes) with the counterterms used to eliminate ultraviolet (UV) divergences in quantum field theory (QFT) perturbation calculations. Through a simple two - dimensional topological gravity model, the paper details how to calculate counter - wormholes using a method similar to the recursive BPHZ process, and shows how this process is controlled by the Faà di Bruno Hopf algebra. This algebraic structure effectively encodes the combinatorics of multi - boundary wormholes and systematically constructs a factorized renormalized gravitational path integral.
In addition, the paper also discusses the broader implications that this method may bring, including how to apply this framework in more complex models and how to combine it with the geometric models of the bulk EFT (effective field theory) to understand the factorization problem in quantum gravity. In this way, the paper not only provides a specific method for solving the Factorization Paradox, but also provides a new perspective for further research on non - locality and topological changes in quantum gravity.