Testing for the Asymmetric Optimal Hedge Ratios: With an Application to Bitcoin

Abdulnasser Hatemi-J

2024-08-01

Abstract:Reducing financial risk is of paramount importance to investors, financial institutions, and corporations. Since the pioneering contribution of Johnson (1960), the optimal hedge ratio based on futures is regularly utilized. The current paper suggests an explicit and efficient method for testing the null hypothesis of a symmetric optimal hedge ratio against an asymmetric alternative one within a multivariate setting. If the null is rejected, the position dependent optimal hedge ratios can be estimated via the suggested model. This approach is expected to enhance the accuracy of the implemented hedging strategies compared to the standard methods since it accounts for the fact that the source of risk depends on whether the investor is a buyer or a seller of the risky asset. An application is provided using spot and futures prices of Bitcoin. The results strongly support the view that the optimal hedge ratio for this cryptocurrency is position dependent. The investor that is long in Bitcoin has a much higher conditional optimal hedge ratio compared to the one that is short in the asset. The difference between the two conditional optimal hedge ratios is statistically significant, which has important repercussions for implementing risk management strategies.

Risk Management,Econometrics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper mainly aims to address the following issues:

1. **Propose a new method to test whether the optimal hedge ratio is asymmetric**: The paper introduces an effective method to examine whether the optimal hedge ratio differs between the positions of buyers and sellers (i.e., whether it is asymmetric). This asymmetry refers to the potential differences in risk sources faced by investors as buyers or sellers, which may lead to different optimal hedge ratios.

2. **Empirical application to Bitcoin**: The paper utilizes the proposed method to conduct an empirical analysis of Bitcoin spot prices and futures prices to verify whether the optimal hedge ratio is asymmetric. The results show that in the Bitcoin market, the conditional optimal hedge ratio for investors holding long positions is significantly higher than for those holding short positions.

In summary, the paper aims to introduce a new statistical testing method to evaluate whether the optimal hedge ratio changes with the direction of investors' positions and to validate this theoretical hypothesis through an empirical study of the Bitcoin market. This method can improve the accuracy of implementing hedging strategies, especially when considering the differences in risk sources for investors as buyers or sellers.