Navketan Batra,D. E. Feldman
Abstract:A striking general bound on the energy gap in topological matter was recently discovered in Ref. [Onishi and Fu, Phys. Rev. X {\bf 14}, 011052 (2024)]. A non-trivial indirect derivation builds on the properties of optical conductivity at an arbitrary frequency. We propose a simpler derivation, allowing multiple generalizations, such as a universal bound on a gap in anisotropic systems, systems with multiple charge carrier types, and topological systems with zero Hall conductance. The derivation builds on the observation that the bound equals $\hbar$ times the ratio of the force by the external electric field on the charge carriers and their total kinematic momentum in the direction perpendicular to the force.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the universal upper limit of the energy gap in topological materials. Specifically, the author tries to provide a simpler and more intuitive derivation method to explain why a non - zero Chern number ($C$) imposes a universal upper limit on the energy gap in topological insulators.
### Background of the Paper
In previous research, Onishi and Fu discovered an astonishing universal upper limit of the energy gap in topological materials, with the expression:
\[
\epsilon_{\text{gap}} \leq \frac{2\pi \hbar^2 n}{|C|m}
\]
where:
- $\epsilon_{\text{gap}}$ is the energy gap,
- $\hbar$ is the reduced Planck constant,
- $n$ is the electron density in a two - dimensional system,
- $C$ is the Chern number,
- $m$ is the electron mass.
The derivation process of this upper limit is rather complex, involving the analysis of the response characteristics of high - frequency circularly polarized light. The author of this paper hopes to provide a simpler derivation method, making this result easier to understand and extend to more situations.
### Main Contributions
1. **Simplified Derivation**: By introducing Newton's law and the concept of momentum, the author provides a more intuitive and rigorous derivation method. Specifically, they observe that the upper limit of the energy gap is equal to $\hbar$ multiplied by the ratio of the force exerted by the external electric field on the carriers to their total momentum:
\[
\epsilon_{\text{gap}} \leq \hbar \left| \frac{F_x}{P_y} \right|
\]
where $F_x$ is the force along the $x$-axis, and $P_y$ is the momentum along the $y$-axis.
2. **Extension to Multiple Situations**: Based on this simplified method, the author further extends this result, including:
- Anisotropic systems
- Systems with multiple carrier types
- Systems with zero Hall conductivity
3. **Extension to Three - Dimensional Systems**: The author also shows how to extend this bound to three - dimensional insulators, obtaining a similar formula for the upper limit of the energy gap.
4. **Systems with Multiple Carrier Types**: For systems with multiple carrier types having different charges $e_\alpha$ and masses $m_\alpha$, the author also provides the corresponding formula for the upper limit of the energy gap.
5. **Spin - Hall Systems**: For spin - Hall systems, the author obtains the upper limit of the energy gap by a similar method.
### Conclusion
Through these works, the author not only simplifies the understanding of the upper limit of the energy gap in topological materials but also extends it to a wider range of situations. This provides new tools and perspectives for further research and understanding of quantum transport phenomena in topological materials.
### Formula Summary
1. Universal upper limit of the energy gap:
\[
\epsilon_{\text{gap}} \leq \frac{2\pi \hbar^2 n}{|C|m}
\]
2. Relationship between momentum and force:
\[
\epsilon_{\text{gap}} \leq \hbar \left| \frac{F_x}{P_y} \right|
\]
3. Upper limit of the energy gap in anisotropic systems:
\[
\epsilon_{\text{gap}} \leq \frac{\pi \hbar^2 n (m_x + m_y)}{|C|m_x m_y}
\]
4. Upper limit of the energy gap in three - dimensional systems:
\[
\epsilon_{\text{gap}} \leq \frac{\hbar e^2 n_{3D}}{|\sigma_{xy}| m}
\]
5. Upper limit of the energy gap in systems with multiple carrier types:
\[
\epsilon_k \leq \frac{\hbar}{|\sigma_{xy}|}