Examining Inequality in Park Quality for Promoting Health Across 35 Global Cities

Linus W. Dietz,Sanja Šćepanović,Ke Zhou,André Felipe Zanella,Daniele Quercia

2024-07-23

Abstract:Urban parks provide significant health benefits by offering spaces and facilities for various recreational and leisure activities. However, the capacity of specific park spaces and elements to foster health remains underexamined. Traditional studies have focused on parks' size, greenery, and accessibility, often overlooking their ability to facilitate specific health-promoting activities. To address this gap, we propose a taxonomy consisting of six categories of health-promoting activities in parks: physical, mind-body, nature appreciation, environmental, social, and cultural. We estimate the capacity of parks in 35 global cities to promote health by establishing a lexicon linking park spaces and elements with specific health-promoting activities from our taxonomy. Using this lexicon, we collected data on elements and spaces in all parks in 35 cities from OpenStreetMap. Our analysis covers 23,477 parks with a total of 827,038 elements and spaces. By first comparing similarly sized parks across cities, we found that North American parks offer more spaces for physical activities, while European parks focus more on nature appreciation. Second, by scoring parks based on both elements and spaces, we investigated the variability in their health-promoting potential. We found the most uniform provision across parks for physical activities and the highest disparities regarding social activities. Additionally, parks offering a variety of activities are usually located in city centers, while offerings diminish in parks towards the suburbs. Lastly, we identified significant inequalities in park standards across cities, regardless of their continental location: Tokyo and Paris offer the most uniform park standards, while Copenhagen and Rio de Janeiro exhibit the most pronounced disparities. Our study provides insights for making urban parks more equitable, engaging, and health-promoting.

Computers and Society,Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the inequality in the ability of urban parks to promote health. Although urban parks are crucial for providing spaces for various leisure and recreational activities, thus bringing significant health benefits, existing research mainly focuses on the size, greenness and accessibility of parks, ignoring their ability to promote specific health activities. To fill this research gap, the author proposes a taxonomy that includes six types of health - promoting activities: physical activities, mind - body activities, nature appreciation, environmental activities, social activities and cultural activities. By creating a glossary to link the spaces and elements in the parks with these health - promoting activities, the author collected data on 23,477 parks in 35 cities around the world and analyzed the potential of these parks in promoting health and the inequality of their distribution.

Specifically, the objectives of the paper include:
1. **Proposing a taxonomy**: Develop a taxonomy covering six types of health - promoting activities to more comprehensively assess the potential of parks in promoting public health.
2. **Data collection and analysis**: Use OpenStreetMap data to collect and analyze the spaces and elements of parks in 35 cities around the world, and evaluate the ability of these parks to support different health - promoting activities.
3. **Revealing inequalities**: By comparing parks in different cities and different areas (such as the city center and the suburbs), reveal the inequalities in the provision of health - promoting activities by parks.
4. **Providing policy recommendations**: Based on the research results, provide improvement suggestions for urban planners and decision - makers to make urban parks more equitable, attractive and conducive to health.

Through these objectives, the paper aims to provide a scientific basis for the design and management of urban parks to better meet the public's health needs.