MedEdit: Counterfactual Diffusion-based Image Editing on Brain MRI

Malek Ben Alaya,Daniel M. Lang,Benedikt Wiestler,Julia A. Schnabel,Cosmin I. Bercea

2024-07-22

Abstract:Denoising diffusion probabilistic models enable high-fidelity image synthesis and editing. In biomedicine, these models facilitate counterfactual image editing, producing pairs of images where one is edited to simulate hypothetical conditions. For example, they can model the progression of specific diseases, such as stroke lesions. However, current image editing techniques often fail to generate realistic biomedical counterfactuals, either by inadequately modeling indirect pathological effects like brain atrophy or by excessively altering the scan, which disrupts correspondence to the original images. Here, we propose MedEdit, a conditional diffusion model for medical image editing. MedEdit induces pathology in specific areas while balancing the modeling of disease effects and preserving the integrity of the original scan. We evaluated MedEdit on the Atlas v2.0 stroke dataset using Frechet Inception Distance and Dice scores, outperforming state-of-the-art diffusion-based methods such as Palette (by 45%) and SDEdit (by 61%). Additionally, clinical evaluations by a board-certified neuroradiologist confirmed that MedEdit generated realistic stroke scans indistinguishable from real ones. We believe this work will enable counterfactual image editing research to further advance the development of realistic and clinically useful imaging tools.

Image and Video Processing,Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper is primarily dedicated to addressing the problem of generating high-quality, realistic counterfactual images in the field of medical imaging, particularly for stroke lesions in brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Specifically, the research team faces the following challenges:

1. **Limitations of Existing Technologies**: Current image editing technologies often fail to generate sufficiently realistic medical counterfactual images. These technologies either cannot adequately simulate indirect pathological effects (such as brain atrophy) or excessively modify the original scan images, resulting in a loss of correspondence with the original images.

2. **Modeling Indirect Pathological Effects**: When generating counterfactual images, it is necessary to balance the relationship between direct pathological changes (such as the stroke lesion itself) and indirect pathological effects (such as other changes caused by the lesion), which is a challenge for existing technologies.

3. **Need for High Fidelity**: To make the generated counterfactual images practically valuable in clinical applications, they must maintain a high degree of consistency with the original scans while also simulating reasonable pathological changes.

To address the above issues, the authors propose MedEdit—a conditional medical image editing method based on a diffusion model. MedEdit is capable of:

- Inducing pathological changes in specific areas while balancing the modeling of disease effects and maintaining the integrity of the original scan.
- Editing medical images through a conditional diffusion model, which can simulate diseases and their actual consequences while maintaining high fidelity to the previous scans.
- Verifying through clinical evaluation that the generated images are both realistic and accurately reflect pathological changes, including both direct and indirect changes.

Experimental results show that MedEdit surpasses existing technologies in several aspects, including the realism of the generated images, consistency with the original scans, and accurate simulation of indirect pathological effects. Additionally, the research emphasizes the gap between existing computational metrics (such as FID and Dice scores) and clinical relevance, calling for the development of more comprehensive evaluation standards that are more closely aligned with clinical practice.