Daytime turbulence strength profile measurement at Kodaikanal Observatory

Saraswathi Kalyani Subramanian,Sridharan Rengaswamy,Prasanna Gajanan Deshmukh,Binukumar G. Nair,Mahesh Babu S
2024-07-19
Abstract:The Indian Institute of Astrophysics (IIA) is developing a Multi-Conjugate Adaptive Optics (MCAO) system for the Kodaikanal Tower Telescope (KTT). In this context, we have measured the daytime turbulence strength profile at the Kodaikanal Observatory. The first method based on wavefront sensor (WFS) images, called S-DIMM+ (Solar-Differential Image Motion Monitor+), was used to estimate the higher altitude turbulence up to a height of 5 - 6 km. The second method used balloon-borne temperature sensors to measure the near-Earth turbulence up to 350 m. We also carried out simulations to validate the performance of our system. We report the first-ever daytime turbulence strength profile measurements at the observatory. We have identified the presence of a strong turbulence layer about 3 km above the observatory. The measured near-Earth turbulence matches the trend that is expected from the model for daytime component of turbulence and gives an integrated $r_0$ of about 4 cm at 500 nm. This is consistent with earlier seeing measurements. This shows that a low-cost setup with a small telescope and a simple array of temperature sensors can be used for estimating the turbulence strength profile at the site.
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? The main purpose of this paper is to measure and characterize the daytime atmospheric turbulence intensity profile at the Kodaikanal Observatory in India. Specifically, the researchers achieve this goal through the following two methods: 1. **S - DIMM+ method**: - Using wave - front sensor (WFS) images, based on the Solar - Differential Image Motion Monitor+ (S - DIMM+), estimate the upper - atmosphere turbulence intensity up to a height of 5 - 6 kilometers. - This method estimates the atmospheric turbulence intensity at different altitude levels by analyzing the differential motion of the solar image in different sub - apertures. 2. **Balloon - borne temperature sensor method**: - Use balloon - borne temperature sensors to measure the atmospheric turbulence intensity in the near - surface layer (up to 350 meters). - The balloon carries multiple temperature sensors and calculates the turbulence intensity by measuring the temperature fluctuations at different heights. ### Research background and significance Atmospheric turbulence has a significant impact on astronomical observations, especially when using Adaptive Optics (AO) systems. Understanding and quantifying the atmospheric turbulence profile at an observatory site is very important for the following aspects: - **Optimizing telescope site selection**: Selecting the best astronomical observation site requires a detailed understanding of the atmospheric turbulence characteristics of the site. - **Improving Adaptive Optics system design**: In order to compensate for the influence of atmospheric turbulence on optical signals, the design of Adaptive Optics systems requires accurate atmospheric turbulence data. - **Increasing observation efficiency**: Through accurate measurement of turbulence intensity, the observation time can be better arranged and the observation efficiency can be improved. ### Main findings - **First daytime turbulence intensity profile measurement**: This is the first daytime turbulence intensity profile measurement at the Kodaikanal Observatory. - **Identification of strong turbulence layer**: A strong turbulence layer was found at approximately 3 kilometers in the study. - **Results consistent with the model**: The turbulence measurement results in the near - surface layer are consistent with the expected daytime turbulence model trend, obtaining an integrated Fried parameter \( r_0 \) of about 4 centimeters (at a wavelength of 500 nanometers). - **Low - cost solution**: The study shows that using a small telescope and a simple array of temperature sensors can effectively estimate the turbulence intensity profile at an observatory site, providing a low - cost solution for other observatories. ### Formula summary The key formulas involved in the paper include: - Relationship between the temperature structure function and the turbulence intensity profile: \[ D_T(r)=C_T^2 r^{2 / 3} \] \[ C_N^2(h)=\left(\frac{80\times 10^{-6} P(h)}{T(h)^2}\right)^2 C_T^2(h) \] - Covariance matrix calculation in the S - DIMM+ method: \[ \langle\delta x_1\delta x_2\rangle=\sum_{n = 1}^{N} c_n F_x(s,\alpha,h_n) \] \[ \langle\delta y_1\delta y_2\rangle=\sum_{n = 1}^{N} c_n F_y(s,\alpha,h_n) \] where, \[ F_x(s,\alpha,h_n)=0.5 I\left(\frac{\alpha h_n - s}{D_{\text{eff},0}}\right)+0.5 I\left(\frac{\alpha h_n + s}{D_{\text{eff},0}}\right)-I\left(\frac{\alpha h_n}{D_{\text{eff},0}}\right) \] \[ F_y(s,\alpha,h_n)=0.5 I\left(\frac{\alpha h_n - s}{D_{\text{eff},0}}\right)+0.5 I\left(\frac{\alpha h_n + s}{D_{\text{eff},0}}\right)-I\left(\frac{\alpha h_n}{D_{\text{eff},0}}\right)