Constraining Weyl type f(Q,T) gravity with Big Bang Nucleosynthesis

Jian Ge,Lei Ming,Shi-Dong Liang,Hong-Hao Zhang,Tiberiu Harko

2024-07-15

Abstract:The Weyl type $f(Q,T)$ modified gravity theory is an extension of the $f(Q)$ and $f(Q,T)$ type theories, where $T$ is the trace of the matter energy-momentum tensor, and the scalar non-metricity $Q$ is represented in its standard Weyl form, and it is fully determined by a vector field $\omega _\mu$. The theory can give a good description of the observational data, and of the evolution of the late-time Universe, including a geometric explanation of the dark energy. In this work we investigate the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) constraints on several Weyl type $f(Q,T)$ gravity models. In particular, we consider the corrections that Weyl type $f(Q,T)$ terms induce on the freeze-out temperature $\mathcal{T}_f$, as compared to the standard $\Lambda$CDM results. We analyze in detail three distinct cosmological models, corresponding to specific choices of the functional form of $f(Q,T)$. The first model has a simple linear additive structure in $Q$ and $T$, the second model is multiplicative in $Q$ and $T$, while the third is additive in $T$ and the exponential of $Q$. For each $f(Q,T)$ we consider first the cosmological evolution in the radiation dominated era, and then we impose the observational bound on $\left|\delta \mathcal{T}_f/ \mathcal{T}_f\right|$ to obtain constraints on the model parameters from the primordial abundances of the light elements such as helium-4, deuterium and lithium-7. The abundances of helium-4 and deuterium agree with theoretical predictions, however, the lithium problem, even slightly alleviated, still persists for the considered Weyl type $f(Q,T)$ models. Generally, these models satisfy the BBN constraints, and thus they represent viable cosmologies describing the entire dynamical time scale of the evolution of the Universe.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to constrain the parameters in the Weyl - type f(Q,T) gravity theory through Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN). Specifically, the author studied the influence of the Weyl - type f(Q,T) gravity theory on the freeze - out temperature \(T_f\) in the standard ΛCDM model and analyzed the performance of three different Weyl - type f(Q,T) gravity models in the cosmological evolution during the radiation - dominated era. By comparing the theoretical predictions with the observed abundances of light elements (such as helium - 4, deuterium and lithium - 7), the author obtained the constraints on these model parameters.

### Background of the paper
The Weyl - type f(Q,T) gravity theory is an extended gravity theory, where \(Q\) is the non - metricity scalar and \(T\) is the trace of the matter - energy - momentum tensor. This theory can well describe the observational data and explain the late - time evolution of the universe, including the geometric interpretation of dark energy. Big Bang Nucleosynthesis refers to the nuclear reaction processes that occurred in the early universe. This process took place within the first few minutes of the existence of the universe and formed isotopes of light elements such as hydrogen, helium and lithium.

### Research methods
1. **Model selection**:
- Model I: \(f(Q,T)=\alpha Q+\frac{\beta}{6\kappa^{2}}T\)
- Model II: \(f(Q,T)=\frac{\gamma}{6H_{0}^{2}\kappa^{2}}QT\)
- Model III: \(f(Q,T)=\eta H_{0}^{2}\exp\left(\frac{\mu}{6H_{0}^{2}}\right)+\frac{\nu}{6\kappa^{2}}T\)

2. **Cosmological evolution in the radiation - dominated era**:
- The author first considered the cosmological evolution in the radiation - dominated era and derived the relationship between the Hubble function and the particle decay rate.
- By comparing the Hubble function with the results of standard general relativity, the influence of the Weyl - type f(Q,T) gravity theory on the cosmological evolution was analyzed.

3. **Constraints on the freeze - out temperature**:
- The author calculated the changes of the freeze - out temperature \(T_f\) under different models and compared them with the results of the standard ΛCDM model.
- Through the observed abundances of light elements (such as helium - 4, deuterium and lithium - 7), the constraints on the model parameters were obtained.

### Main results
- **Abundances of helium - 4 and deuterium**: The abundances of helium - 4 and deuterium predicted by the models are consistent with the theoretical expectations.
- **Lithium problem**: Although the abundance of lithium - 7 has been slightly improved, the lithium problem still exists.
- **Constraints on model parameters**: By comparing the theoretical predictions with the observational data, the author obtained the specific constraint ranges of the model parameters.

### Conclusions
The Weyl - type f(Q,T) gravity theory can satisfy the constraints of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis, so these models are effective candidates for describing the entire dynamic evolution time scale of the universe. In particular, these models perform well in the cosmological tests of the early universe and provide a new perspective for understanding the early evolution of the universe.

### Formula display
- **Relationship between the Hubble function and the particle decay rate**:
\[
H(T_f)=\Gamma_{\text{tot}}(T_f)\approx c_qT_f^{5}
\]
where \(c_q = 4A4!\approx9.8\times 10^{-10}\text{GeV}^{-4}\).

- **Deviation of the freeze - out temperature**:
\[
\left|\frac{\delta T_f}{T_f}\right|<4.7\times 10^{-4}
\]

- **Constraint on the abundance of helium - 4**:
\[
Y_{4\text{He}}=0.2485\pm0.0006 + 0.0016\left[(\eta_{10}-6)+100(Z - 1)\right]
\]

- **Constraint on the abundance of lithium - 7**:
\[
\frac{7\t