Abstract:The emergence of high order harmonics in carrier pumping from magnetic dynamics in the presence of spin-orbit coupling has been only recently predicted [{Phys. Rev. B \textbf{105}, L180415 (2022)}]. In this effect, the number of the excited high harmonics is found to scale up with the spin-orbit coupling parameter, the s-d exchange constant of the magnetic system and the frequency of the driving dynamics. Motivated by the reproduction of the above-mentioned effect, Nikolić and Manjarres [<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2212.06895" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.06895">arXiv:2212.06895</a>, <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2112.14685" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.14685">arXiv:2112.14685</a>] confirmed that there is indeed a generation of harmonics as a result of the interplay between magnetic dynamics and spin-orbit interaction if the exchange coupling $J$ is taken very small ($J=0.1\gamma$). However, they claim that the ultrahigh harmonics obtained in the strong $J$ limit can only be a result of numerical bugs. It turns out that in these works, conclusions built from numerical simulations performed in the perturbative limit ($J/\hbar\omega\approx 10$) have been applied to criticize results obtained in the extremely high non-linear regime ($J/\hbar\omega>10^3$). Regarding this fact, we find it necessary to shed light on many aspects related to the physics behind the predicted unconventional carrier pumping, in order to enlighten the readers of the proposed effect and at the same time the authors of the criticizing works. Here, we present numerical simulations of the scaling laws underlying the effect. We study the low s-d exchange coupling limit, corresponding to the regime studied in the above mentioned criticizing works. And further explore, the high s-d coupling regime where the extremely nonlinear emission is expected. Furthermore, we provide more insights on the effect and demonstrate its robustness and reproducibility in both 1D and 2D magnetic structures.

Comment on "Charge pumping with strong spin-orbit coupling: Fermi surface breathing, Berry curvature, and higher harmonic generation"

Charge pumping with strong spin-orbit coupling: Fermi surface breathing, Berry curvature, and higher harmonic generation

Spin-orbit coupling induced ultrahigh-harmonic generation from magnetic dynamics

Scaling laws of the magnetic dynamics driven high harmonic generation in spin-orbit coupled systems

High harmonic generation from electrons moving on topological spin textures

Magnetic dynamics driven integer and fractional high harmonic generation arising from highly nonlinear instantaneous energy levels

High-harmonic generation in spin and charge current pumping at ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic resonance in the presence of spin-orbit coupling

Comment on "Spin-orbit coupling induced ultrahigh-harmonic generation from magnetic dynamics" with prescriptions on how to validate scientific software for computational quantum transport

Magnonic Charge Pumping via Spin-Orbit Coupling

Noncollinear antiferromagnetic textures driven high-harmonic generation from magnetic dynamics in the absence of spin-orbit coupling

Resonant second harmonic generation in a two-dimensional electron system

Terahertz high-harmonic generation in gapped antiferromagnetic chains

Spin high-harmonic generation through terahertz laser-driven phonons

Analogue of Charge Conjugation in the Optical Spin Hall Effect

Ultrafast and Strong-Field Physics in Graphene-Like Crystals: Bloch Band Topology and High-Harmonic Generation

Role of Spin-Orbit Coupling in High-order Harmonic Generation Revealed by Super-Cycle Rydberg Trajectories

Nonclassical states of light after high-harmonic generation in semiconductors: a Bloch-based perspective

Generation of High-Order Harmonics with Hybrid Spin and Transverse Orbital Angular Momentum from a Crystalline Solid

Giant Spin-Orbit Induced Magnon Nonreciprocity in Ultrathin Ferromagnets

Magnon kinetic theory of the antiferromagnetic Hanle effect

Terahertz oscillation in a noncollinear antiferromagnet under spin-orbit torques