On unsolvable equations of prime degree

Juliusz Brzeziński,Jan Stevens
2024-06-20
Abstract:Kronecker observed that either all roots or only one root of a solvable irreducible equation of odd prime degree with integer coefficients are real. This gives a possibility to construct specific examples of equations not solvable by radicals. A relatively elementary proof without using the full power of Galois theory is due to Weber. We give a rather short proof of Kronecker's theorem with a slightly different argument from Weber's. Several modern presentations of Weber's proof contain inaccuracies, which can be traced back to an error in the original proof. We discuss this error and how it can be corrected.
Number Theory,History and Overview
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the real - number properties of the roots of irreducible polynomial equations of odd prime degrees. Specifically: 1. **Kronecker's Observation**: For a solvable irreducible equation with integer coefficients and of odd prime degree, all of its roots are either all real or there is only one real root. This observation can be used to construct specific examples of equations that cannot be solved by radicals. 2. **Weber's Elementary Proof**: Weber gave a relatively elementary proof, using limited knowledge of field extensions, but this proof has some problems and inaccuracies. 3. **Correction and Discussion**: The paper discusses the errors in Weber's proof and proposes methods on how to correct these errors. In addition, the paper also provides a shorter proof of Kronecker's theorem, using a different line of argument from Weber. ### Specific Problem Description - **Background**: Historically, Galois theory was used to prove that high - degree equations do not have radical - like solutions as quadratic, cubic or quartic equations. The work of Kronecker and Weber provided more elementary methods for this. - **Objective**: The objective of the paper is to re - examine Kronecker's theorem and provide a more rigorous and shorter proof method by correcting Weber's proof. At the same time, the paper also explores the problems existing in other related proofs in history. ### Main Contributions - **Historical Review**: The paper reviews in detail the work of Kronecker and Weber and their positions in the history of mathematics. - **New Proof**: Provides a new, shorter proof of Kronecker's theorem, avoiding the errors in Weber's original proof. - **Error Analysis and Correction**: Analyzes in detail the errors in Weber's proof and proposes a correction plan to ensure the correctness and rigor of the proof. ### Conclusion Through the above work, the paper not only clarifies certain misunderstandings in historical literature, but also provides a more elementary and intuitive approach for understanding and teaching Galois theory. This helps students and researchers better understand the properties of the roots of irreducible polynomials and their relationship with Galois theory.