Exploring the Impact of AI-generated Image Tools on Professional and Non-professional Users in the Art and Design Fields

Yuying Tang,Ningning Zhang,Mariana Ciancia,Zhigang Wang

2024-06-15

Abstract:The rapid proliferation of AI-generated image tools is transforming the art and design fields, challenging traditional notions of creativity and impacting both professional and non-professional users. For the purposes of this paper, we define 'professional users' as individuals who self-identified in our survey as 'artists,' 'designers,' 'filmmakers,' or 'art and design students,' and 'non-professional users' as individuals who self-identified as 'others.' This study explores how AI-generated image tools influence these different user groups. Through an online survey (N=380) comprising 173 professional users and 207 non-professional users, we examine differences in the utilization of AI tools, user satisfaction and challenges, applications in creative processes, perceptions and impacts, and acceptance levels. Our findings indicate persistent concerns about image quality, cost, and copyright issues. Additionally, the usage patterns of non-professional users suggest that AI tools have the potential to democratize creative processes, making art and design tasks more accessible to individuals without traditional expertise. This study provides insights into the needs of different user groups and offers recommendations for developing more user-centered AI tools, contributing to the broader discussion on the future of AI in the art and design fields.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore the impact of AI-generated image tools on professional and non-professional users in the fields of art and design. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Usage Differences Among Different User Groups**: The study examines the application, user satisfaction, and challenges of AI-generated image tools among different user groups through an online survey (with a total of 380 participants, including 173 professional users and 207 non-professional users).

2. **Application in the Creative Process**: The paper analyzes how AI-generated image tools are applied in the creative process, including different stages from concept generation to actual creation, and explores the integration of these tools with other software (such as ChatGPT, Photoshop, etc.).

3. **Perception and Impact**: The study also investigates users' views on AI-generated image tools and their potential positive and negative impacts, such as advantages in enhancing inspiration, saving time and costs, as well as concerns about copyright issues and the similarity of generated content.

4. **Acceptance Level**: Finally, the paper evaluates users' attitudes towards AI tools, including whether they see them as auxiliary tools or true partners, and whether they are willing to continue using these tools in the future.

Through the above research, the authors hope to understand the usage of AI-generated image tools among different user groups and their potential democratizing effect, i.e., how these tools lower the entry barriers in the fields of art and design, enabling more people without traditional professional knowledge to participate in creative activities. Additionally, the study provides specific suggestions for improving AI tools to meet the needs of different users, further promoting innovation and development in the fields of art and design.