A Calibration Approach for Elasticity Estimation with Medical Tools

Sarah Grube,Maximilian Neidhardt,Anna-Katarina Herrmann,Johanna Sprenger,Kian Abdolazizi,Sarah Latus,Christian J. Cyron,Alexander Schlaefer

2024-06-14

Abstract:Soft tissue elasticity is directly related to different stages of diseases and can be used for tissue identification during minimally invasive procedures. By palpating a tissue with a robot in a minimally invasive fashion force-displacement curves can be acquired. However, force-displacement curves strongly depend on the tool geometry which is often complex in the case of medical tools. Hence, a tool calibration procedure is desired to directly map force-displacement curves to the corresponding tissue elasticity.We present an experimental setup for calibrating medical tools with a robot. First, we propose to estimate the elasticity of gelatin phantoms by spherical indentation with a state-of-the-art contact model. We estimate force-displacement curves for different gelatin elasticities and temperatures. Our experiments demonstrate that gelatin elasticity is highly dependent on temperature, which can lead to an elasticity offset if not considered. Second, we propose to use a more complex material model, e.g., a neural network, that can be trained with the determined elasticities. Considering the temperature of the gelatin sample we can represent different elasticities per phantom and thereby increase our training data.We report elasticity values ranging from 10 to 40 kPa for a 10% gelatin phantom, depending on temperature.

Tissues and Organs

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problem of accurately estimating the elasticity of soft tissues in minimally invasive surgery. Specifically, the author focuses on how to obtain force - displacement curves through robot - assisted palpation and directly map these curves to the corresponding tissue elasticity values. Due to the complex geometry of medical tools, the force - displacement curves are closely related to the tool geometry, so a calibration method is required to ensure the accuracy of elasticity estimation.

### Main problems and solutions in the paper

1. **Problem description**:
- **Estimation of soft tissue elasticity**: Soft tissue elasticity is related to different disease stages and can be used for tissue identification, especially during minimally invasive surgical procedures.
- **Force - displacement curves depend on tool geometry**: Due to the complex geometry of medical tools, it is difficult to directly map force - displacement curves to tissue elasticity.
- **Effect of temperature on elasticity**: Experiments show that the elasticity of gelatin samples is highly dependent on temperature, which may lead to elasticity estimation bias.

2. **Solutions**:
- **Experimental device**: The author proposes an experimental device for calibrating medical tools using robots. Through this device, indentation experiments can be efficiently carried out.
- **Material model**: First, estimate the elastic modulus of gelatin samples using a standard contact model (such as the Hertz model). Then, considering the influence of temperature, use a more complex material model (such as a neural network) for training.
- **Study of temperature dependence**: Systematically evaluate the change in elasticity of gelatin samples at different temperatures and find that temperature significantly affects the elastic modulus.
- **Neural network training**: Use the temperature - corrected elasticity values as training data to train a neural network to predict tissue elasticity in actual surgeries.

### Key formulas

1. **Hertz model formula**:
\[
F=\frac{4}{3}\frac{E}{1 - \nu^{2}}R_{\text{ind}}^{1/2}d^{3/2}
\]
where:
- \(F\) is the loading force,
- \(E\) is Young's modulus,
- \(\nu\) is Poisson's ratio (assumed to be 0.5),
- \(R_{\text{ind}}\) is the radius of the spherical indenter,
- \(d\) is the indentation depth.

2. **Formula for temperature - dependent elastic modulus**:
\[
E=- 0.06T_{\text{ph}}^{2}-0.13T_{\text{ph}} + 41.42
\]
where:
- \(E\) is Young's modulus,
- \(T_{\text{ph}}\) is the temperature of the gelatin sample (unit: °C).

### Conclusion

Through the above methods, the author shows that different tissue elasticities can be simulated by changing the temperature of gelatin samples, thereby reducing the time for generating gelatin samples and improving the accuracy of elasticity estimation. In addition, considering the temperature factor can significantly reduce the deviation of training data, enabling the neural network to predict tissue elasticity more accurately.