Mean Field Study of Superconductivity in the Square Lattice $t$-$J$ Model with Three-Site Hopping

Ke Yang,Qianqian Chen,Lei Qiao,Zheng Zhu

2024-08-01

Abstract:It remains an open question whether the two-dimensional single-band pure Hubbard model and its related pure $t$-$J$ model truly capture the superconducting order in cuprates. Recent numerical studies on this issue have raised a notable disparity in superconducting order between the pure Hubbard model and the pure $t$-$J$ model. Inspired by these, we investigate the role of the three-site hopping term in $d$-wave superconductivity, such a term is usually neglected in the effective Hamiltonian of the Hubbard model, though its amplitude is of the same order as the superexchange coupling $J$ in the $t$-$J$ model. Our slave-boson mean-field solution demonstrates the suppression of $d$-wave superconducting order by incorporating the three-site hopping term, consistent with numerical observations by the density matrix renormalization group. This suppression could be understood as a result of competition between superexchange interaction and three-site hopping, the former favors $d$-wave pairing while the latter favors $s$-wave pairing. We also discussed its role in quasiparticle dispersion and boson-condensation temperature. Our findings may offer an alternative understanding of the recent numerical contrasting findings in the strong coupling regime: the absent or weak superconductivity in the pure Hubbard model, while the robust superconductivity in the $t$-$J$ model without including the three-site hopping term.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the two - dimensional single - band pure Hubbard model and its related pure t - J model can truly capture the superconducting order in copper - based superconductors. Specifically, the author focuses on the role of the three - site hopping term in d - wave superconductivity. Although this term is usually ignored in the effective Hamiltonian of the Hubbard model, its magnitude is on the same order of magnitude as the superexchange coupling J in the t - J model. Through research, the author finds that the introduction of the three - site hopping term can suppress the d - wave superconducting order, which is consistent with the numerical observations of the density - matrix renormalization group (DMRG). This suppression can be understood as the result of the competition between the superexchange interaction and the three - site hopping. The former is favorable for d - wave pairing, while the latter tends to s - wave pairing. In addition, the author also discusses the role of the three - site hopping term in quasiparticle dispersion and boson condensation temperature. These findings may provide a new understanding for the recent numerical comparison results in the strong - coupling region, that is, the absence or weakness of superconductivity in the pure Hubbard model and the strong superconductivity in the t - J model without the three - site hopping term.